Creative wood-fired pizzas with sourdough crust and a standout garden patio; excellent flavors but counter-service model, variable service speed, and premium pricing divide opinion.
All Souls Pizza delivers solid neighborhood dining through excellent sourdough crust and creative seasonal toppings paired with a genuinely appealing garden patio that justifies its destination appeal. However, inconsistent topping distribution and limited table service due to the counter model prevent grade A-grade performance. The premium pricing and modest portions work for the casual garden-dining experience, making it a worthwhile stop for pizza enthusiasts who value setting and ingredient quality over flawless execution.
One caveat: Pricing feels high for portion size to some diners, especially desserts and drinks