Seemor
Palermo & North › Belgrano › New Jonathan
New JonathanC-Proceed Cautiously
Av. Lidoro J. Quinteros 1200, C1428BXQ Cdad. Autónoma de Buenos Aires, Argentina
· Restaurant, Bar, Cafe
· 4.4/5 Google (4410 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Classic Argentine spot near River Plate Stadium with broad menu and mixed execution; good when on form, but slow service and inconsistencies are common.
Why it gets a C- for overall quality
New Jonathan delivers classic Argentine comfort food in a convenient stadium-adjacent location, but inconsistent cooking and temperature control combined with repeated service delays limit its appeal beyond casual pre- or post-game visits. Isolated but serious food safety complaints regarding undercooked items add concern. Best suited for families seeking familiar Argentine staples and game-day convenience rather than reliable quality dining.
Restaurant Summary
Steps from the Monumental, New Jonathan feels like a classic neighborhood cafe-restaurant where game-day crowds and families mix. Service ranges from warmly welcoming to frustratingly slow, with one diner noting it was warm and cozy while another described long waits. Expect a traditional room that reads a bit vintage and a staff that can be either attentive or overwhelmed depending on the night. The cooking leans Argentine comfort: steaks, milanesas, house pastas, and big picadas. When the kitchen hits, dishes like bacon-wrapped beef or a simple provoleta satisfy; at other times plates can arrive underseasoned or not at ideal temperature. Think classic over creative, with breadth for most tastes but variable execution; it suits pre- and post-stadium meals or casual family outings more than special-occasion finesse. Families will find plenty kids will eat: milanesas, pastas, fries, and grilled chicken. There is no clear kids menu, but portions and simple preparations work for younger palates. If you need speed before kickoff, arrive early; waits can be long, and on cold days the room may feel drafty.
At a Glance
- Stadium-adjacent location ideal for pre/post River Plate visits
- Broad Argentine menu with crowd-pleasing staples
- Service delays and cold dishes reported by multiple groups
- Inconsistent cooking and temperature control
- Isolated but serious food safety complaint
What Sets It Apart
- proximity_to_estadio_monumental
- very_broad_menu
- classic_argentine_comforts
What People Love
- Convenient location by the stadium
- Comforting classics like provoleta and steaks
- Cozy vintage cafe vibe
- Reasonable pricing on many staples
Points of Concern
- Long waits to order and for mains during busy times; some meals arrived cold
- Reports of undercooked milanesas and reheated pork items
- Pricing feels high to some relative to quality, especially on event days
- Isolated but serious food poisoning report; caution advised
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average CostARS 7,000-12,000 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Pair a shared picada with pastas for value; request doneness clearly for steaks; confirm cheese or condiments for pastas since not always offered proactively
Perfect For
- Pre- or post-game bite near Estadio Monumental
- Casual family lunch with classic Argentine dishes
- Large picadas and simple pastas with friends
- Tourists visiting the River museum looking for nearby meal
Location Insights
Area: Residential-sport corridor by Estadio Monumental; pre/post-game crowds and museum visitors mix with locals.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked on event days; quieter and routine urban caution off-peak.
Nearby: River Plate Stadium, club museum, broad avenues; parking demand spikes on match days.
PalermoPalermo is a trendy and expansive neighborhood famous for its lively nightlife, boutique shops, and a wide variety of restaurants and bars. It attracts a diverse crowd looking for innovative dining experiences and social atmospheres, making it one of the city's premier gastronomic destinations.
Palermo HollywoodPalermo Hollywood is known for its concentration of media companies and a vibrant culinary scene featuring modern restaurants, cocktail bars, and cafes. It offers a hip, cosmopolitan vibe popular among locals and visitors seeking contemporary dining and nightlife.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday07:00–02:00
Tuesday07:00–02:00
Wednesday07:00–02:00
Thursday07:00–02:00
Friday07:00–03:00
Saturday07:00–03:00
Sunday07:00–02:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →