Seemor
Margie's CandiesB-Worth Trying
1813 W Montrose Ave, Chicago, IL 60613
· Ice cream shop, Restaurant
· 4.6/5 Google (1355 reviews)
Takeout
Classic Chicago ice cream parlor with giant sundaes, warm hot fudge, and nostalgic charm; expect crowds and occasional service hiccups.
Why it gets a B- for overall quality
Margie's Candies delivers classic soda-fountain charm with strong food quality highlighted by signature hot fudge and generous portions, but inconsistent execution—occasional melted ice cream and flavor outages—prevents a higher grade. The exceptional vintage setting and destination appeal as a Chicago institution are genuine strengths, yet cramped seating and limited comfort constrain the overall experience. Worth visiting for the nostalgic atmosphere and reliable sundaes, though expect variable service quality and crowded conditions.
Restaurant Summary
Step into Margie’s and it feels like time travel: marble soda fountain, vintage booths, and sundaes arriving on platters with a warm pitcher of fudge. One diner summed it up: "The fudge was heavenly and the sundae was massive." Crowds build at peak times, the room can feel cramped and lively, and service ranges from cheerful to harried near closing. The cooking is classic soda-fountain fare rather than creative cuisine: thick shakes, turtle sundaes, banana splits, and that signature hot fudge. The approach leans nostalgic and portion-driven more than chef-y, which is exactly why people come—shareable desserts, familiar flavors, and little wafers tucked on the side. Families do well here. Junior sundaes and splits offer kid-sized choices, and most items are sweet, simple, and recognizable. Seating is tight and waits are common on warm nights, so consider the to-go window if restless kids or strollers are in the mix.
At a Glance
- Warm hot fudge and oversized sundaes define the experience
- Charming vintage atmosphere with strong local nostalgia
- Crowds, cramped seating, and confusing order flow at peak
- Topping surcharges and occasional quality inconsistencies
- Check hours; closing-time service can be curt
What Sets It Apart
- house_hot_fudge_in_pitcher
- vintage_soda_fountain_atmosphere
- oversized_shareable_sundaes
What People Love
- That warm fudge pitcher moment
- Shareable, photo-worthy sundaes
- Old-school charm and memorabilia
- Friendly, quick service when seated
Points of Concern
- Ordering flow can be confusing between table, counter, and outside window during rush
- Reports of curt service near closing and inconsistent friendliness at the window
- Topping surcharges (e.g., pecans) feel steep to some guests
- Occasional quality dips: melted scoops, mushy banana, flavor outages
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleHybrid
Average Cost$14-$22 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Share one Jumbo Banana Split ($13.95) for two; add a single shake ($7.95) if still peckish
- If you love nuts, budget extra for pecans on turtle sundaes
- Junior Sundae ($7.95) is a smart pick for kids
Perfect For
- Post-dinner dessert runs
- First-date nostalgia trips
- Family treat nights
- Out-of-towner Chicago must-try sweets
Location Insights
Area: Transit-adjacent, neighborhood vibe under the Brown Line with steady foot traffic and family appeal.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked corridor; occasional sidewalk congestion noted.
Nearby: Near Montrose Brown Line, mix of small shops and eateries; popular post-dinner dessert stop.
LakeviewLakeview is a lively and diverse neighborhood with a strong community feel, known for its bustling commercial corridors, theaters, and dining options ranging from casual eateries to upscale restaurants. The area is popular for its accessibility to Lake Michigan, nightlife, and family-friendly amenities, making it a well-rounded dining and social destination.
Roscoe VillageRoscoe Village is a charming, walkable enclave within Lakeview characterized by its small-town feel, independent shops, and cozy dining spots. It attracts locals looking for a neighborhood vibe with quality casual dining and community events.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–22:00
Tuesday11:00–22:00
Wednesday11:00–22:00
Thursday11:00–22:00
Friday13:00–22:00
Saturday11:00–22:00
Sunday11:00–22:00
Available: Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →