Reservations · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Cozy Lincoln Park gastropub with strong cocktails, beloved burger and brunch, but service inconsistency and occasional kitchen misses mean experiences can vary.
The Monkey's Paw delivers reliable neighborhood gastropub dining with strong food quality anchored by a celebrated burger and crispy Brussels sprouts, though inconsistent execution on off nights prevents higher grades. Exceptional design appeal with cozy rustic interiors and a thoughtful cocktail program elevate the experience, but service variability and occasional delays during rushes keep it competitive with respected local favorites rather than a destination establishment.
The room feels warm and cozy with exposed brick, shelves of books, and a tucked-away fireplace nook that regulars claim in colder months. Service often comes off friendly and welcoming, and more than a few diners call the cocktails thoughtful. One guest summed it up: "Neighborhood comfort with a grown-up bar program." While most visits are smooth, some report service hiccups during rushes. The cooking leans elevated comfort food more than culinary fireworks. Think a buzzed-about burger, crispy Brussels sprouts, and a chicken sandwich that wins converts, with brunch favorites like French toast and breakfast poutine. On off nights, a few plates land bland or delayed, so expectations should skew toward a cozy gastropub rather than a chef-driven destination. Families do fine here thanks to familiar crowd-pleasers like burgers, fries, grilled cheese, and shareable apps. Brunch is an easy win with bottomless mimosas for adults and straightforward plates for kids, though noise near the bar can nudge families toward the quieter back room or patio in fair weather.
Area: Upscale residential with young professionals and families; neighborhood bar-restaurant vibe near DePaul and boutique retail.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit streets with steady evening foot traffic.
Nearby: Close to DePaul University, boutiques, and other bars; good pre- or post-event option.
Available: Reservations, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →