Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Lively underground sports pub with standout wings, big portions, and tons of TVs; service and noise can be uneven, and policies/fees occasionally frustrate.
Timothy O'Toole's delivers solid neighborhood pub dining with strong food quality in wings, burgers, and shareables that exceed typical bar standards. Inconsistent execution on certain items and occasional service rough edges at the host stand prevent a higher grade, though friendly, attentive servers and a vibrant basement atmosphere with extensive sports viewing make it a reliable late-night destination near the Magnificent Mile.
Down the stairs off Fairbanks, this place opens into a lively basement pub where TVs glow from every angle and servers hustle between shareable plates and pints. Reviewers describe staff who are often friendly and quick, with the occasional rough edge at the host stand or bar. One guest summed it up as better than your average bar food, with wings, burgers, and a pretzel bread pudding that wins over skeptics. On big games, it can be loud and buzzing enough to swallow conversation. The cooking leans classic pub fare: crispy wings with lots of sauces, stacked burgers, ribs, and hearty bowls rather than chef-y flourishes. Think portion-forward comfort that hits the spot when hot and seasoned well. There are high points (those wings and Irish nachos) and a few frequent misses (shepherd pie and soups draw mixed reviews), so order to the kitchen’s strengths. This is a reliable stop for sports viewing and late-night food when other kitchens have gone dark. For families, the menu is kid-accessible—burgers, fries or tots ($5), tacos, and chicken bowls—though the room can be very noisy during games. One review noted under-21 was allowed before 7pm, but policies can vary with events. If bringing little ones, target earlier hours and stick to simple, familiar items like burgers, fries, or the rice bowl.
Area: Busy downtown Streeterville near Magnificent Mile; mix of residents, office workers, hospital visitors, and tourists.
Safety: Generally safe, high foot traffic, well lit; typical downtown late-night bustle.
Nearby: Near hotels, Northwestern medical campus, Michigan Avenue shopping, offices; strong game-day and late-night draw.
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →