Reservations · Outdoor seating
Stylish Cotswold gastropub-inn with excellent woodfired cooking and Sunday roasts; service and rooms delight many, though inconsistencies and policy rigidity frustrate some.
The Double Red Duke delivers solid A-grade performance through exceptional food quality anchored in confident woodfired cooking and contemporary British technique, paired with outstanding setting appeal that captures authentic Cotswold charm. However, inconsistent execution during peak times—with reports of cold dishes and service delays—and variable room comfort prevent the higher distinction needed for grade A territory. This is a characterful, well-executed neighborhood restaurant that competes with the area's better establishments, ideal for leisurely meals and special occasions when timing aligns.
Set in a postcard Cotswold village, this inn-restaurant feels warm and cozy with snugs, roaring fires, and a lively grill counter. Guests rave about friendly faces like Tom and Max, while one diner noted, "service was lovely, if stretched on a busy Sunday." The setting is rustic-luxe rather than formal, perfect for slow afternoons and celebratory dinners by the hearth. In the kitchen, the team leans contemporary British with woodfired cooking and produce-forward plates: roast sirloin with proper gravy, bone-in sirloin by the grill, woodfired cod with bright gremolata, and a twice-baked cheese soufflé. Flavors are confident with modern nudges (miso, labneh, harissa) without veering into theatrics. Most visits sing; a minority report delays or cooler plates at peak times, so expect high craft and some bustle. Families do well here thanks to a real kids menu (sausage and mash, pizzetta, cod scampi) and forgiving classics like chips and sticky toffee. Veggie mains and sides help non-meat eaters, though past vegan roast confusion suggests confirming details. For Sunday lunch, book ahead and request trimmings up front to avoid disappointment.
Area: Quaint Cotswold village setting attracting weekenders and locals; rustic-luxe countryside vibe with nearby walks and cozy pubs.
Safety: Generally safe rural area with low crime; quiet at night and good daylight foot traffic.
Nearby: Near Masons Arms sister pub; countryside trails, historic stone cottages, destination inns drawing visitors.
Available: Reservations, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →