Seemor
Mr Hot PotatoB+Worth Trying
12 Wolseley Pl, Edinburgh EH8 7AD
· Takeout Restaurant, Fast food restaurant
· 4.8/5 Google (132 reviews)
Takeout
Beloved local spot for giant, value-packed jacket potatoes with friendly banter; expect queues and a simple takeaway setup.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Mr Hot Potato earns its grade through exceptional food quality and outstanding service attentiveness that consistently delight regulars and newcomers alike. Steady execution over years and remarkable customer loyalty confirm reliable quality, while limited seating and takeaway-focused format prevent the higher grades reserved for full-service dining destinations. For what it is—a neighborhood favorite delivering best-in-class baked potatoes with genuine warmth—it performs exceptionally well.
Restaurant Summary
A cheerful little takeaway where the counter chat is as warming as the food, Mr Hot Potato draws locals and visitors with friendly banter and mountains of fillings. One diner put it simply: best baked potato in town. Expect a straightforward setup, quick service, and the kind of regulars who know their order by heart. The cooking sticks to classic comfort rather than culinary fireworks: fluffy jacket potatoes with hearty toppings like chicken tikka, chilli con carne, and beans with cheese. The culinary approach leans traditional and portion-led: familiar flavors, generous scoops, and value first. If you want creative fusion, look elsewhere; if you want a hot, satisfying spud that eats like a meal, this is it. For families, this is easy and kid-friendly. The menu offers simple wins kids actually eat—beans and cheese, buttered potatoes, fries—plus mild options like coronation chicken. No dedicated kids menu is needed because sizes are large; consider sharing for younger eaters.
At a Glance
- Exceptional value for money with very large portions
- Warm, friendly owner and quick counter service
- Consistently praised potatoes and classic fillings
- Primarily takeaway with limited seating
- Occasional product shortages reported at busy times
What Sets It Apart
- giant_jacket_potatoes
- decades_long_local_following
- warm_owner_interaction
What People Love
- Fluffy potatoes with crisped skin
- Hearty, well-seasoned fillings like tikka and chilli
- Genuine warmth from the owner
- Portions that feel like a bargain
- Reliability over many years
Points of Concern
- Primarily a takeaway; seating appears limited
- One-off complaint about rude service contrasts with broader praise
- Occasional stock shortages at peak times
- Review patterns show some ultra-low-activity accounts; overall authenticity remains good
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost£9-14 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- For vegetarians: Beans and Cheese or Coleslaw and Butter (£5.95-7.95).
- For halal: Several fillings noted as halal by reviewers; confirm at counter.
- For kids: Buttered potato (£3.95) or Beans and Cheese (£7.95), share if needed.
Perfect For
- A fast, filling lunch on a budget
- Post-park comfort food grab
- Feeding teens with hearty appetites
- Simple, unpretentious takeaway dinner
Location Insights
Area: Residential-meets-local high street near Holyrood, everyday footfall with students and families.
Safety: Generally safe with steady daytime foot traffic; standard urban awareness at night.
Nearby: Close to Holyrood Park and housing; handy for quick eats before walks or errands.
BrunswickBrunswick is a quiet, primarily residential area just south of the University of Edinburgh. It offers a calm atmosphere with a selection of local cafes, pubs, and casual dining spots catering to students and residents. The dining scene is relaxed and community-oriented, with easy access to the bustling Old Town nearby.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–19:00
Tuesday11:00–19:00
Wednesday11:00–19:00
Thursday11:00–19:00
Friday12:00–19:00
Saturday12:00–19:00
Sunday
Available: Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →