Seemor

Old Chain PierB+Worth Trying

Name: Old Chain Pier
Address: 32 Trinity Cres, Edinburgh EH5 3ED, Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Rating: 4.5

32 Trinity Cres, Edinburgh EH5 3ED · Restaurant, Pub · 4.5/5 Google (2142 reviews)

Reservations · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Spectacular waterfront pub-restaurant with standout fish and chips and Cullen skink, friendly but occasionally inconsistent service, creative-leaning seafood touches, and pricing that aligns with the view more than pure comfort-food value.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

Old Chain Pier trades on spectacular waterfront views and reliable staples like fish and chips and Cullen skink, earning its grade B+ standing. Exceptional setting appeal and strong interior design anchor the experience, but inconsistent food quality across visits and stretched service during peak periods prevent higher recognition. Best suited for diners prioritizing scenic dining and casual pub comfort over culinary precision.

Restaurant Summary

A seaside pub-restaurant with sweeping views of the Firth of Forth, Old Chain Pier leans into big waterfront appeal. Guests talk about lingering over dessert while watching the water and praise staff who shift them to the prized window seats. One diner summed it up: "The view alone felt magical," while acknowledging that at peak times service can feel stretched and slow. In the kitchen, the approach is pub comfort with a coastal accent, edging into creative here and there—think Cullen skink, crisp haddock, mussels, and occasional twists like gin-cured carpaccio. The culinary approach leans elevated traditional: reliable staples with a few contemporary flourishes rather than chefly theatrics. Order fish and chips or Cullen skink for the highest hit rate; fried mixed baskets and occasional specials draw mixed notes. Families are well served: there is a clear kids section with mini fish, goujons, and burgers around £6. Vegan and vegetarian options exist (vegan burger, halloumi salad, mushrooms on toast), but gluten-free diners should note shared fryers and a coeliac warning from reviewers. Expect a scenic, crowd-pleasing menu rather than bespoke allergen handling.

At a Glance

Spectacular waterfront setting with coveted window tables
Fish and chips and Cullen skink earn consistent praise
Service can be slow or brusque at peak times; time limits enforced when late
Pricing feels high to some; service charge reported by multiple diners
Kid-friendly menu and relaxed pub atmosphere

What Sets It Apart

panoramic_waterfront_views
Scottish_seafood_focus
live_music_nights

What People Love

Atmospheric sea views that make a meal feel special
Crisp haddock with proper chips
Hearty Cullen skink on blustery days
Friendly staff who try to honor window-seat requests

Points of Concern

Service pace varies; several reports of long waits and delayed communication
Perceived high drink prices and automatic service charge on some bills
Inconsistent execution on some fried platters and occasional menu item outages
Gluten-free safety concerns (shared fryers, mix-ups reported by a coeliac)
Review patterns show normal polarity for scenic venues; no strong manipulation signals

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost£34-48 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

For reliable value: Soup of the day + Fish & Chips (~£23-28 before drinks).
Vegan diners: Choose Vegan Burger (£15.95) or Wild Mushrooms on Toast (£9.95); confirm fryer use.
Kids: Mini fish, goujons, or burger meals are £6.00 and straightforward.

Perfect For

Sunset seafood and a pint by the water
Casual date with a view
Family lunch with kid-friendly options
Out-of-town visitors wanting a scenic Edinburgh spot

Location Insights

Area: Harborside residential district with seaside walks; draws locals and visitors for waterfront views and sunsets.

Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked waterfront; typical urban caution at night but no systemic safety flags in reviews.

Nearby: On the Firth of Forth with vistas toward Fife; near Newhaven Harbour, tram and bus access within walking distance.

TrinityTrinity is a primarily residential neighborhood within Leith, characterized by its Victorian and Edwardian architecture and proximity to green spaces and the waterfront. The dining scene here is more subdued compared to central Leith, with local pubs, cafes, and a few quality restaurants catering to residents and visitors seeking a relaxed environment.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday12:00–22:00 Tuesday12:00–22:00 Wednesday12:00–22:00 Thursday12:00–22:00 Friday12:00–23:00 Saturday12:00–23:00 Sunday12:00–21:00

Available: Reservations, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →