Seemor
StarbarCWorth Trying
1 Northumberland Pl, Edinburgh EH3 6LQ
· Pub
· 4.6/5 Google (533 reviews)
Outdoor seating
Characterful New Town pub with a warm crowd, lively music nights, and a hidden beer garden; expect friendly vibes, occasional service rough edges, and prices a touch above basic locals.
Why it gets a C for overall quality
Starbar delivers a distinctive neighborhood experience anchored by strong destination appeal and exceptional repeat-visitor loyalty. Service warmth varies noticeably by staff and moment, and food remains secondary to drinks and music, preventing higher grades. The hidden cobbled location and heated beer garden create genuine charm that keeps regulars returning for atmosphere and programming rather than culinary distinction.
Restaurant Summary
Down a cobbled New Town lane, Starbar feels like a neighborhood hideaway where the music matters and regulars gather. The room leans quirky and cozy, with pride flags, art, and a garden out back that glows under heaters even in winter. As one guest put it, the team can make you feel like long-lost friends, though a few visitors hit service that felt brusque on a bad night. It is a spot where the playlist and crowd shape the evening into something warm and buzzing. The culinary approach leans drinks-first and music-forward, not a food destination. Expect a classic pub bar with Guinness, craft picks like Gamma Ray, and festival-season energy. In spirit, it is traditional pub culture with creative programming rather than culinary theatrics; think open mic, DJs, and that lived-in character. It suits those who want atmosphere over polish and conversation over courses. Families during the day can make use of the heated beer garden, and the easygoing setup works for a quick soft drink or a low-key pint. There is no clear kids menu or food focus noted in reviews, so plan snacks accordingly. For cautious palates, stick to familiar pours; for adventurous nights, the events calendar and lively crowd keep it interesting.
At a Glance
- Welcoming staff and regulars culture create an instant-local feel
- Hidden heated beer garden expands space and comfort
- Engaging programming with open mic, DJs, and bands
- Service tone can swing from charming to curt depending on staff and situation
- Drinks can feel a bit pricey for some, typical of New Town
What Sets It Apart
- hidden_beer_garden_with_heaters
- lively_open_mic_and_dj_nights
- distinctive_quirky_decor
- strong_regulars_culture
What People Love
- Feeling welcomed like a regular from first visit
- Playlist curation and open mic energy
- Quirky decor with personality and pride
- Heated beer garden that works year-round
Points of Concern
- Service inconsistency: a few reports of rudeness or dismissive tone, especially around house rules
- Complaint handling: off beer incidents acknowledged but not replaced in some cases
- Pricing surprise: some items (e.g., premium soft drinks) run higher than expected for a pub
- Review patterns show signs of potential manipulation (staff name repetition, festival-season enthusiasm), though overall risk appears low
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost£14-20 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Try the Guinness if you like a classic pour; explore a single craft beer before committing to rounds to check freshness.
Perfect For
- Pre-gig or post-festival pints with friends
- Solo drop-ins to meet locals and catch live tunes
- Casual date night in a characterful pub
- Daytime hang in a heated garden
Location Insights
Area: Historic New Town side street with cobbled lanes; attracts locals, artists, and festival-goers.
Safety: Generally safe, steady foot traffic; typical central Edinburgh safety profile.
Nearby: Near residential terraces, boutique shops, and other pubs; popular during festival season and evenings.
New TownThe dining scene in New Town is diverse, featuring a mix of high-end restaurants, trendy cafes, and traditional pubs. The area attracts a sophisticated crowd looking for quality dining experiences in a stylish and historic setting, with a lively yet refined social atmosphere.
Northumberland StreetNorthumberland Street is a quieter, more residential part of New Town with boutique eateries and casual dining spots. It offers a more relaxed dining environment compared to the busier Princes Street nearby, appealing to those seeking a calm yet central location.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday16:00–23:00
Tuesday16:00–23:00
Wednesday16:00–23:00
Thursday16:00–01:00
Friday15:00–01:00
Saturday14:00–01:00
Sunday15:00–23:00
Available: Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →