Seemor
The Banshee LabyrinthBWorth Trying
29-35 Niddry St, Edinburgh EH1 1LG
· Pub, Night club, Bar
· 4.5/5 Google (2951 reviews)
A beloved gothic maze-bar with gigs, cinema, and strong alt vibes, but multiple complaints about door security and karaoke hosting require expectation management.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
The Banshee Labyrinth delivers a genuinely distinctive nightlife experience anchored by unmatched gothic vault ambiance and paranormal lore that makes it a must-visit for alt culture and live music fans. Atmosphere remains reliably atmospheric, and reasonable pricing for a central Old Town venue adds appeal. However, recurring door security friction and inconsistent entry-level service prevent higher standing—this is a venue you visit for the experience and music, not hospitality polish.
Restaurant Summary
The Banshee Labyrinth is an underground warren of stone rooms where heavy riffs and horror vibes echo through gothic vaults. Reviewers rave about the atmosphere, calling it a “spooky maze with character,” and many make this their go-to nightcap. Inside staff are often warm, but a recurring theme is that door security can feel harsh, shaping first impressions more than the cocktails or cinema do. The culinary approach is purely bar-side—think cocktails, pints, and ciders—while the creativity lives in the venue concept itself: cinema screenings, gigs, karaoke, and paranormal lore. If you are into alt nights and intimate gigs, this hits the spot; if you are after dinner or craft mixology theatre, look elsewhere. The experience leans contemporary and event-driven rather than food-focused, ideal for music-forward nights. Families should know this is an adult nightlife venue. There is no food program mentioned in reviews, and the focus is on late-night events, loud music, and security-controlled entry. Teens at shows crop up occasionally, but for most families, nearby restaurants will be a better fit before you head here for drinks and music.
At a Glance
- Unmatched gothic maze ambiance with cinema and live gigs
- Reasonable central pricing for drinks per many reviewers
- Repeated reports of rude or inflexible door security
- Karaoke host tone and song restrictions frustrated some guests
- Friendly bar staff and helpful sound tech noted by several visitors
What Sets It Apart
- underground_cinema_in_bar
- haunted_vaults_setting
- strong_alt_music_programming
What People Love
- The spooky underground maze aesthetic
- Cinema screenings of horror films
- Loud alt/metal playlists and live gigs
- Reasonably priced drinks for the location
- A welcoming vibe once inside with friendly bartenders
Points of Concern
- Door security frequently cited as rude, inconsistent, or discriminatory by multiple reviewers
- Karaoke host behavior and song restrictions upset several groups
- Crowded rooms and maze layout can feel chaotic on busy nights
- Toilet cleanliness and maintenance fluctuate at peak hours
- Review patterns show no manipulation but experiences vary sharply by entry interactions
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost£16-26 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Based on review mentions, stick to cocktails, pints, or cider; plan dinner elsewhere before visiting.
Perfect For
- Pre- and post-gig bar hopping in Old Town
- Alt and metal fans seeking a distinctive venue
- Horror enthusiasts chasing haunted-lore experiences
- Small groups exploring multi-room nightlife
Location Insights
Area: Historic Old Town lane with alternative nightlife, tourists and students; late-night energy.
Safety: Busy nightlife zone; typical late-night rowdiness; standard city-center vigilance advised.
Nearby: Near Royal Mile, underground vaults venues, fringe spaces, other pubs and clubs.
CowgateCowgate is a lively and eclectic part of Edinburgh's Old Town, famous for its nightlife, pubs, and diverse eateries ranging from casual to trendy. The area attracts a mix of university students, visitors exploring the city, and locals enjoying the vibrant social atmosphere, especially in the evenings.
Niddry StreetNiddry Street is a small but notable micro-neighborhood within Cowgate, known for its historic pubs and proximity to major tourist attractions like Edinburgh Castle. It offers a slightly quieter but still lively dining environment compared to the busier Cowgate main strip.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday19:00–03:00
Tuesday19:00–03:00
Wednesday19:00–03:00
Thursday19:00–03:00
Friday17:00–03:00
Saturday17:00–03:00
Sunday19:00–03:00
View full analysis on Seemor →