Seemor

The Edinburgh Larder - Blackfriars StreetA-Worth Trying

Name: The Edinburgh Larder - Blackfriars Street
Address: 15 Blackfriars St, Edinburgh EH1 1NB, Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Rating: 4.6

15 Blackfriars St, Edinburgh EH1 1NB · Restaurant, Breakfast restaurant, Brunch restaurant · 4.6/5 Google (4110 reviews)

Reservations · Takeout

A beloved Old Town brunch spot for high-quality Scottish breakfasts, great coffee, and friendly service, though queues, a one-hour seating policy, and automatic service charge can frustrate.

Why it gets an A- for overall quality

The Edinburgh Larder delivers exceptional Scottish breakfast execution with quality local ingredients and warm, proactive service that earns its A-grade standing. Reliable execution across most visits supports repeat visits, though tight seating and the one-hour policy create operational friction that prevents grade A territory. A destination for serious breakfast seekers in Edinburgh's Old Town, but operational constraints and occasional service inconsistencies keep it from elite status.

Restaurant Summary

Set in Edinburgh’s Old Town, this cafe feels warm and bustling from the moment you join the queue. Travelers rave about crisp-edged potatoes, runny yolks, and friendly staff who often go the extra mile—one guest said the team was so kind they helped even when no purchase was needed. Be aware of the one hour seating policy and an automatic service charge that some find off-putting; once you are seated, the focus shifts to quick, capable service and seriously good coffee. The cooking leans classic Scottish with care toward local sourcing, an elevated-traditional approach rather than showy fusion. Expect well-executed staples like the Full Scottish with haggis and black pudding, eggs Benedict or Florentine with silky hollandaise, and a trout-and-romesco hash that eats brighter than you would guess. Portions are satisfying without being over the top, pricing is mid-market for the area, and value comes from quality ingredients more than bells and whistles. Families are welcome here, with a proper kids menu that includes cheesy beans on toast, waffles with syrup, and simple sandwiches at wallet-friendly prices. If your little ones prefer straightforward flavors, there are safe picks; adventurous eaters can sample veggie haggis or smoked trout. Space is tight and time-limited during peak hours, so families may be happiest with a reservation and clear expectations about the pace.

At a Glance

Standout Scottish breakfasts with quality local ingredients
Friendly, attentive service that resolves issues proactively
Strong vegetarian and vegan options plus a real kids menu
One-hour seating policy and queues can feel rushed
Automatic 12.5% service charge surprises some guests

What Sets It Apart

locally_sourced_scottish_breakfasts
runny_egg_excellence
smoked_trout_specialties
dedicated_kids_menu

What People Love

Runny, perfectly poached eggs
Crispy herb potatoes in the hash
Belhaven smoked trout and quality bacon/haggis
Warm, personable staff who fix problems quickly

Points of Concern

Strict seating rules (one-hour cap) and queue management can feel brusque during rushes
Automatic service charge added by default; some feel pressured to keep it
Annex seating may serve meals in tins/boxes, which some find awkward
Isolated complaints about cold bread or bland soup indicate occasional inconsistency

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost£25-34 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

For vegetarians, choose Veggie Breakfast or Eggs Florentine; vegans should opt for Vegan Breakfast or miso roast cauliflower sandwich.
Families: kids waffles or cheesy beans on toast are reliable hits.
Lunch hunters: Roast chicken or sea trout sandwich deliver value around £13.50.

Perfect For

A proper Scottish breakfast before sightseeing
Family brunch with reliable kids options
Solo coffee and eggs on a weekday morning
Visitors seeking local-produce-focused cafe fare

Location Insights

Area: Historic, tourism-heavy Old Town corridor drawing visitors for sights, with steady footfall from nearby Royal Mile and Cathedral.

Safety: Busy, well-trafficked tourist zone; generally safe with typical city-center crowds.

Nearby: Near St Giles Cathedral and Royal Mile attractions; surrounded by cafes, pubs, tours, and shops.

BlackfriarsBlackfriars is a lively area within Edinburgh's Old Town, characterized by its proximity to major attractions like the Royal Mile and Edinburgh Castle. The dining scene here is diverse, ranging from traditional Scottish pubs to contemporary restaurants, catering to both visitors and locals seeking quality food in a historic setting. The area is pedestrian-friendly and bustling, especially during festival seasons.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday07:30–15:00 Tuesday07:30–15:00 Wednesday07:30–15:00 Thursday07:30–15:00 Friday07:30–15:00 Saturday08:00–15:00 Sunday08:00–15:00

Available: Reservations, Takeout

View full analysis on Seemor →