Seemor
The Joker And The ThiefB+Worth Trying
71 Elm Row, Edinburgh EH7 4AQ
· Pub
· 4.5/5 Google (729 reviews)
Reservations · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Lively Leith Walk pub with friendly bartenders, quality beers, quirky decor, and order-in pizza; great vibe but occasional management-related service conflicts.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
The Joker And The Thief delivers solid neighborhood pub performance through genuinely friendly bartenders and knowledgeable whisky guidance, supported by reliable execution and quirky, memorable decor. Beer quality and pizza from Origano meet expectations without distinction. Occasional management friction and off-site pizza delays prevent higher standing, but the pub competes well with respected local favorites for casual, convivial drinking.
Restaurant Summary
This Leith Walk pub feels warm and bustling without tipping into chaos. Bartenders earn shout-outs for whisky coaching and easygoing charm, and the room is decked with quirky memorabilia. One guest put it simply: "Felt like my local on the first visit." However, occasional managerial clashes show up in a few reviews. The culinary approach leans classic pub drinking with pizza support from Origano next door—traditional and crowd-pleasing rather than creative. Expect quality pours (Guinness and continental lagers get love), a rotating cask, and mid-teens pizzas like Funghi with truffle notes or spicy Calabrese. It suits people who want good beer and an easy hang, not tasting-menu theatrics. Families fare well earlier in the day: pizza, simple flavors, and relaxed seating help. There is no kids menu per se, but Margherita and pepperoni are safe bets. Noise is lively but manageable; plan around peak times if your crew prefers low-key moments.
At a Glance
- Friendly bartenders who guide whisky and beer choices
- Fair drink prices for central Edinburgh
- Quirky decor and lively events (quiz, close-up magic)
- Occasional manager-related service conflicts
- Pizza delays can occur since food is prepared off-site
What Sets It Apart
- whisky_guidance_from_staff
- order-in_pizza_partner
- quirky_pop_culture_decor
- weekly_magic_or_quiz_nights
What People Love
- Welcoming staff who remember faces
- Consistently good pints of Guinness and continental lagers
- Order-in pizzas that pair well with beer
- Decor that sparks conversation
- Buzzing vibe without ear-splitting volume
Points of Concern
- Management conflicts reported by several guests, including ejections and heated exchanges
- Pizza wait times can be long during peak hours due to external kitchen
- Busy periods limit large-group seating flexibility
- Review patterns show no manipulation, but expectations should consider mixed service incidents
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost£26-34 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Vegetarians will find solid options (Margherita, Funghi, Verdure – Bianca)
- Ask about spicy choices like Calabrese or Vesuvio if you want heat
- Pair richer pizzas with malty ales; lighter pies with crisp lagers
Perfect For
- Casual pints before or after a show
- Whisky-curious drinkers seeking guidance
- Low-stakes meetups with friends
- Dog-friendly daytime hang
Location Insights
Area: Bustling Leith Walk corridor with indie bars, cafes, and mixed local-tourist footfall.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked main street; standard urban awareness at night.
Nearby: Near city centre; buses along Leith Walk; shops, cafes, and other pubs adjacent.
New Town EastA lively area blending residential and commercial spaces with a mix of traditional pubs, modern eateries, and boutique shops. The dining scene is diverse, catering to both locals and visitors seeking casual and upscale options in a historic setting.
Elm Row CorridorA busy street connecting the Old Town to the New Town, featuring a variety of casual dining spots, cafes, and takeaway outlets popular with students and office workers. The atmosphere is energetic and accessible, with a mix of quick bites and relaxed dining.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday15:00–00:00
Tuesday15:00–00:00
Wednesday15:00–01:00
Thursday15:00–01:00
Friday13:00–01:00
Saturday13:00–01:00
Sunday15:00–00:00
Available: Reservations, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →