Reservations · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Central Tuscan restaurant-pasticceria with very affordable pasta and crostoni, solid savory dishes for many, excellent pastry for some, but repeated reports of dual pricing and service inconsistency require vigilance.
Ricordi delivers respectable quality in a convenient central location, with solid food quality in savory dishes offsetting inconsistent pastries. However, service variability and reliability concerns—compounded by recent complaints about pricing clarity and overcharging—prevent a higher grade. The prime Duomo setting attracts walk-in traffic but doesn't elevate the overall experience beyond competent neighborhood trattoria standards.
Right off the Duomo, Ricordi blends a lively pastry counter with a sit-down trattoria room that feels casual and central. Guests describe a steady flow of museum-goers, soft jazz, and servers who are either warm and attentive or distracted at rush—opinions truly split. Several diners warn to check menus closely due to table vs bar pricing differences. On the plate, the cooking leans classic Tuscan comfort: pici with ragout, peposo, porcini risotto, and a lineup of tagliata and filet steaks with optional truffle. The savory kitchen earns praise more consistently than the pastry case, which looks stunning but can vary—some mignon and hot chocolate wow, while certain cakes and tiramisu read dry or overly creamy. Prices for pasta and crostoni are friendly for the location; premium steaks and truffle add-ons climb accordingly. Families do fine here thanks to simple pastas and burgers, plus the fun of choosing sweets next door. Kids who like straightforward flavors will find spaghetti al pomodoro, cacio e pepe, and fries easy wins. Be aware that a cover may apply and table-service drinks can cost more than the counter; confirm which menu you are using before you sit down.
Area: Steps from the Duomo on a busy pedestrian corridor; heavy tourist flow with some local foot traffic.
Safety: Well-lit, high footfall tourist core; generally safe with standard pickpocket caution.
Nearby: Near Cathedral of Santa Maria del Fiore, Accademia, retail streets; constant museum and shopping crowds.
Available: Reservations, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →