Seemor

Piccola StoriaB+Worth Trying

Name: Piccola Storia
Address: Bentinckstraat 30, 1051 GL Amsterdam, Netherlands, 1051 GL Amsterdam
Rating: 4.9

Bentinckstraat 30, 1051 GL Amsterdam, Netherlands · Pizza restaurant · 4.9/5 Google (394 reviews)

Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Tiny Westerpark pizzeria turning out standout Neapolitan pies with joyful Italian hospitality and fair prices; mostly takeaway with a couple seats, worth a detour for pizza lovers.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

Piccola Storia delivers exceptional Neapolitan pizza quality with warm, attentive service and impressive speed, earning solid respect among Amsterdam pizza enthusiasts. However, the takeaway-focused format and severely limited seating prevent the full dining experience needed for a higher grade—this is neighborhood counter pizza, not a destination restaurant. Fair pricing for artisan quality and genuine local charm make it worth seeking out if you appreciate authentic Neapolitan craft.

Restaurant Summary

The room is tiny, the oven glows, and the vibe is unmistakably Naples with football memorabilia and cheerful banter. Service feels warm and genuine, the kind of place where the owner remembers faces. As one diner put it, "this little counter spot makes pizza you travel for," especially if you carry it to nearby Westerpark for a slice of neighborhood magic. The cooking leans classic Neapolitan: light, elastic dough, charred edges, and high-quality ingredients over showiness. Favorites like Margherita, Diavola, and the house Maradona deliver big flavor without fuss, ideal for purists who care about dough and balance rather than novelty. Pricing is fair for the craft, and waits are typically just an oven cycle thanks to a streamlined counter flow. For families, this is an easy win if kids like pizza—simple options like Margherita and Quattro Formaggi suit younger palates, though seating is very limited. Plan for takeaway or a quick perch at the few spots outside. No kids menu needed here; share a pie or two and head to Westerpark for a relaxed picnic.

At a Glance

Benchmark-quality Neapolitan dough with excellent ingredient quality
Friendly, welcoming Italian team and neighborhood feel
Strong value at €13-19 per pizza
Very limited seating; primarily takeaway
Occasional Margherita wetness reported on isolated visit

What Sets It Apart

maradona_theme
neighborhood_institution_feel
visible_wood_fired_oven

What People Love

Light, leopard-spotted crust that still satisfies
Cheerful hospitality that feels like Naples
House favorite Maradona pizza with burrata
Consistent quality across years of visits
Fair neighborhood pricing

Points of Concern

Space is tiny with one or two spots; expect takeaway at peak times
A minority noted watery Margherita on one visit; most experiences were excellent
No formal table service; counter model may not suit sit-down seekers

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleCounter With Seating Average Cost€16-23 per person ReservationsNot required

What to Order

Start with Margherita to judge the dough and sauce, then try Maradona for burrata richness
Vegetarians have multiple strong options including Quattro Formaggi and Tartufo e Funghi

Perfect For

Grabbing a top-tier pizza to eat in the park
Casual midweek dinner without reservations
Solo slice-and-go cravings
Purists chasing authentic Neapolitan pies

Location Insights

Area: Residential-meets-creative zone near Westerpark with local hangouts and relaxed neighborhood vibe.

Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked, popular park nearby; typical central Amsterdam lighting and footfall.

Nearby: Close to Westerpark; mix of cafes, bars, and small shops; good for takeaway to the park.

De BaarsjesDe Baarsjes is a lively, multicultural neighborhood with a strong community feel and an emerging reputation for innovative dining and cozy cafes. The area is popular among young professionals and artists, offering a mix of traditional Dutch and international influences in its social and dining scenes.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday17:30–21:30 Tuesday17:30–21:30 Wednesday17:30–21:30 Thursday17:30–21:30 Friday17:30–21:30 Saturday17:30–21:30 Sunday17:30–21:30

Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →