Seemor
Key West › Key West › Kermit's Key Lime Pie Shop - 335F Duval Street
Kermit's Key Lime Pie Shop - 335F Duval StreetB-Worth Trying
335F Duval St, Key West, FL 33040
· Bakery, Dessert shop
· 4.6/5 Google (1306 reviews)
Takeout
Destination for classic and flavored key lime pies with grab-and-go vibes on Duval; excellent for dessert stops, mixed on service, solid value for slices.
Why it gets a B- for overall quality
Kermit's Key Lime Pie Shop delivers what it promises: a bright, Instagram-friendly stop with solid food quality centered on its signature tart-creamy balance. However, quality variation across slices and occasional service inconsistencies prevent a higher grade, while recent mixed feedback on flavor and service suggests some softening. For a quick dessert on Duval Street, it's a reliable choice—just manage expectations for a casual counter experience rather than polished dining.
Restaurant Summary
Right on Duval Street, this shop feels bright and lively, drawing visitors in with lime-green decor, free samples, and the promise of a tart-sweet slice. One traveler summed it up: "We popped in for a slice and a photo, and left with a box." Expect fast counter service and a quick sugar stop more than a sit-down cafe. The cooking is classic dessert fare with a single-minded key lime focus: original, coconut, strawberry, plus chocolate-dipped frozen bars. Most praise the balanced, creamy tang, though a handful report slices that run too sweet, too sour, or a touch gritty. If you love classic flavors over culinary theatrics, this is a reliable crowd-pleaser for a quick treat. Families do well here: slices, candies, cookies, and a listed kids menu mean easy wins for picky eaters. Slices run about $6 and whole pies near $22-$25, so dessert for the family stays reasonable. Seating is limited, so be ready to take it to go.
At a Glance
- Tart-cream balance on classic and flavored key lime pies
- Prime Duval Street location with quick counter service
- Inconsistent slices reported (too sweet, too sour, or gritty)
- Occasional rude counter-service interactions
- Gluten-free slice and kid-friendly sweets
What Sets It Apart
- iconic_key_lime_focus
- duval_street_location
- chocolate_dipped_pie_on_a_stick
What People Love
- Bright lime decor and fun vibe
- Chocolate-dipped pie bars on a stick
- Coconut key lime pie balancing tartness
- Free samples of cookies and candies
- Reliable stop for classic key lime flavor
Points of Concern
- Taste variability: some slices reported as too sweet, too sour, or slightly gritty
- Limited seating; mostly counter service and takeaway
- A few complaints about rude staff interactions at the counter
- Shipping/travel pack complaints from isolated cases when using carriers
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$12-$20 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Choose coconut if you want gentler tartness
- Gluten-free slice available for wheat avoidance
- Travel packs help pies survive the journey home
Perfect For
- Post-dinner dessert walk on Duval
- Sweet stop during sightseeing
- Quick family treat break
- Grab-and-go gifts and souvenirs
Location Insights
Area: Touristy main strip with constant foot traffic, souvenir shops, bars, and sweet stops.
Safety: Busy, well-lit pedestrian corridor; typical tourist crowds and daytime safety.
Nearby: Near bars, trolley routes, and attractions; cruise visitor flow common.
Old TownOld Town is characterized by its charming, historic buildings and a bustling dining scene that ranges from casual cafes to upscale seafood restaurants. The area is lively and tourist-friendly, with many establishments catering to visitors looking for local flavors and unique experiences.
Duval StreetDuval Street is the main commercial strip in Old Town, famous for its bars, restaurants, shops, and entertainment venues. It is the epicenter of nightlife and casual dining in Key West, attracting a diverse crowd throughout the day and night.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday10:00–21:30
Tuesday10:00–21:30
Wednesday10:00–21:30
Thursday10:00–21:30
Friday10:00–21:30
Saturday10:00–21:30
Sunday10:00–21:30
Available: Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →