Seemor

Moose McGillycuddy's - KiheiBWorth Trying

Name: Moose McGillycuddy's - Kihei
Address: 2511 S Kihei Rd, Kihei, HI 96753, Kihei, United States
Rating: 4.4

2511 S Kihei Rd, Kihei, HI 96753 · Restaurant, American restaurant, Bar · 4.4/5 Google (2142 reviews)

Takeout

Lively second-floor sports bar with ocean views, strong happy hour, and crowd-pleasing bar fare; service and food can be inconsistent and access is stair-only.

Why it gets a B for overall quality

Moose McGillycuddy's delivers solid neighborhood sports bar dining with exceptional ocean and sunset views that elevate the experience beyond typical bar fare. Food quality leans toward satisfying comfort fare—burgers, fish and chips, and tacos shine—but inconsistent execution on busy nights and variable service reliability during peak times prevent a higher grade. Strong happy hour value and a loyal regular following make this worth visiting for the vibe and deals, though not as a fine-dining destination.

Restaurant Summary

Up a flight of stairs in central Kihei, Moose feels like a beach-town clubhouse: TVs glowing, sunset peeking through the front, and bartenders who learn names fast. Guests rave about lively game-day energy and views where someone even spotted whales. One regular put it simply: "They had our game on and our drinks ready in minutes." Do expect crowds, the occasional seat shuffle, and that unmistakable sports bar buzz. The cooking leans comfort-first bar fare with local touches—think mahi fish and chips, kalua pork, poke-inspired plates, wings, and big burgers. Value spikes on Tuesday tacos and happy hour, where portions and prices make this an easy call after the beach. Food quality is usually satisfying if you order to the strengths, but it can swing on busy nights; some diners loved the mahi while others found a French dip forgettable. If you come for the vibe, views, and deals, you will likely leave happy. Families fit right in here. Kids orbit toward burgers, fries, and tacos, and the TVs keep them entertained. The current menu shows veggie tacos and simple options that many children will eat. Note the second-floor stairs mean no elevator access, so strollers and wheelchairs face a real barrier.

At a Glance

Ocean views and sunset seats elevate the sports bar vibe
Strong Happy Hour and Taco Tuesday value
Friendly bartenders who remember regulars
Food and service can be inconsistent during peak times
Second-floor stair access only (no elevator)

What Sets It Apart

ocean_view_second_floor
bingo_and_trivia_nights
taco_tuesday_deals

What People Love

That carefree Maui sports energy
Quick game requests handled on the spot
Taco Tuesday deals that feel like a win
Sunset and occasional whale-spotting from upstairs
Bartenders who make you feel like a regular

Points of Concern

Access: second-floor stairs only; multiple reviews could not dine due to no elevator
Peak-hour strain: long waits, seating mix-ups, or slow refills during games
Dish variability: burgers and French dip draw mixed reviews; nachos can be under-seasoned
Review patterns show typical bar hyperbole but overall appear organic and credible

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost$32-$48 per person ReservationsNot required

What to Order

Choose seafood plates (mahi, coconut shrimp) when freshly prepped
Use taco deals to sample multiple proteins without overspending
Veggie tacos offer a simpler option if traveling with mixed diets

Perfect For

Watching big games with a view
Casual group meetups after the beach
Budget-friendly HH and taco nights
Solo bar dining with attentive bartenders

Location Insights

Area: Beach-adjacent, casual vacation hub with condos and surf beaches; heavy game-day bar energy.

Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked tourist corridor with evening foot traffic; standard beach-town lighting.

Nearby: Across from Kamaole Beach Park condos; near Fred’s Mexican and shopping; sunset views from second floor.

KiheiKihei is a laid-back beach town with a strong local community and a steady influx of tourists. The dining scene is diverse, featuring casual eateries, seafood shacks, and family-friendly restaurants, often with ocean views and a relaxed atmosphere.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday11:00–22:00 Tuesday11:00–22:00 Wednesday11:00–22:00 Thursday11:00–22:00 Friday11:00–22:00 Saturday11:00–22:00 Sunday11:00–22:00

Available: Takeout

View full analysis on Seemor →