Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Wood-fired pizza from a friendly Kihei food truck with standout Lilikoi Pork and thin, char-kissed crusts, but portions run small and service can be inconsistent at peak times.
Outrigger Pizza Co delivers strong food quality with its signature thin, wood-fired crusts and local-inspired toppings like Lilikoi Pork, earning solid marks for execution when the oven cooperates. However, inconsistent results—ranging from top-tier pies to undercooked or light-topped versions—and moderate service reliability prevent a higher grade. The relaxed island vibe and friendly crew suit casual dining expectations, making it a worthwhile neighborhood spot for wood-fired pizza enthusiasts who can tolerate occasional waits and variable outcomes.
In a tucked-away Kihei lot, Outrigger turns out wood-fired pies with thin, blistered crusts and a laid-back, picnic-table setup. Reviews describe a friendly crew and that island-casual ease: "They called us when our pie was ready". Expect a relaxed outdoor vibe more than polish, and some waits when the oven is humming. The cooking leans classic pizza with a Maui twist—think Lilikoi Pork, Maui onion with truffle salt, and the usual pepperoni and three-cheese standbys. When the bake is spot on, the crust balances chew and char; on off nights, a few diners found it light on toppings or underdone. Best for those who enjoy simple, wood-fired pies with a local accent rather than elaborate creations. Families do well here: kids gravitate to cheese and pepperoni, and the casual seating makes it easy. Portions are personal-sized, so order accordingly. No formal kids menu needed—just plan one pie per child and skip long peak-hour waits if patience is short.
Area: Relaxed beach-town vibe with mix of locals and visitors; casual outdoor dining common.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked during day and early evening; typical parking-lot lighting at night.
Nearby: Food truck lot off the main drag; near beaches, condos, and casual eateries.
Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →