Seemor

Old Mary'sBWorth Trying

Name: Old Mary's
Address: the mitre pub, 24 Craven Terrace underneath, London W2 3QH, London W2 3QH, United Kingdom
Rating: 4.6

the mitre pub, 24 Craven Terrace underneath, London W2 3QH · Wine bar, Bar · 4.6/5 Google (170 reviews)

Reservations

A quirky, atmospheric basement bar in Bayswater with friendly staff, a speakeasy vibe, and a loyal following—best for drinks and ambiance, not for food or cocktails.

Why it gets a B for overall quality

Old Mary's delivers a compelling bar experience through distinctive atmospheric appeal and exceptional staff warmth and attentiveness, but the grade reflects its true identity as a drinks-focused venue rather than a full dining destination. Limited food offerings and cramped seating prevent higher standing, while recent shifts toward wine focus and inconsistent drink execution create some reliability concerns. Worth visiting for the unique speakeasy atmosphere and personable service, but manage expectations around food and space.

Restaurant Summary

Old Mary's is a quirky, atmospheric basement bar tucked away in Bayswater, London, offering a unique speakeasy vibe that feels like a step back in time. The space is filled with nooks, crannies, and gothic charm, making it a favorite for those seeking something off the beaten path. Staff are consistently praised for their warmth and attentiveness, with several guests mentioning memorable interactions and personalized recommendations. The bar is especially popular for casual drinks, private parties, and date nights, with a loyal following of both locals and travelers who stumble upon its hidden entrance. Culinary-wise, Old Mary's leans heavily into its identity as a wine and drinks bar. Recent reviews highlight a shift away from cocktails toward a wine-focused menu, though some guests still reminisce about the classic cocktails of years past. Food is not the main attraction here—expect simple snacks like cheese plates rather than a full meal. The ambiance is lively and energetic, with music and a cozy, sometimes cramped, setting that adds to its underground charm. If you're looking for a creative culinary experience or substantial dining, this may not be your spot, but for drinks and atmosphere, it's a winner. For families with kids: This is not a family-oriented venue. There are no mentions of kid-friendly food or activities, and the focus is squarely on adult beverages and a grown-up vibe. Seating is cozy and space is limited, so families with young children may find it uncomfortable. If you're seeking a place for a family meal, the larger pub/restaurant upstairs may be a better fit.

At a Glance

Unique, atmospheric basement speakeasy with historic charm
Exceptionally friendly and attentive staff create a welcoming vibe
Great for private parties and casual drinks with friends
No longer serves cocktails—now primarily a wine bar
Not suitable for families or those seeking a full meal
Menu and drink offerings have changed recently; check before visiting

What Sets It Apart

historic_basement_setting
speakeasy_vibe
friendly_staff

What People Love

The hidden, speakeasy vibe and historic basement setting
Staff who go out of their way to make guests feel welcome
Memorable private parties and group celebrations
The cozy, quirky atmosphere that's unlike anywhere else
Personalized drink recommendations and local stories

Points of Concern

Recent shift away from cocktails to wine bar focus has disappointed some regulars
Space can feel cramped and seating comfort is mixed
Not suitable for families or those seeking a meal
Some inconsistency in drink quality and service speed, especially in the past

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost£20-30 (multiple drinks and bar snacks, based on review mentions) per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

Stick to wine and cheese pairings for the best experience.
If cocktails are important to you, call ahead to confirm availability.
Plan for light snacks, not a full meal.

Perfect For

Impromptu date nights in a quirky setting
Small group gatherings or private parties
Travelers seeking a hidden London bar experience
Locals looking for a cozy, atmospheric spot for drinks

Location Insights

Area: Trendy, historic, and slightly quirky basement bar scene in Bayswater, popular with locals and travelers seeking a unique experience.

Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked area near hotels and residential streets; no safety concerns noted in reviews.

Nearby: Close to Bayswater Road, Paddington, and Hyde Park; surrounded by hotels, pubs, and other bars.

BayswaterA cosmopolitan area with a vibrant dining scene, characterized by diverse international restaurants, proximity to Hyde Park, and a blend of Victorian architecture and modern amenities.

Lancaster GateAn upscale sub-area with elegant residential streets, close to Hyde Park, featuring sophisticated dining and drinking establishments.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday17:00–23:00 Friday17:00–00:00 Saturday15:00–00:00 Sunday17:00–22:00

Available: Reservations

View full analysis on Seemor →