Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Creative Hawaiian-inspired pizzas with standout crust and vegan/GF options, but expect occasional long waits and inconsistent service; BYOB and patio seating are pluses.
Black Rock Pizza delivers solid neighborhood dining with flavorful Hawaiian-inspired pizzas and a relaxed island atmosphere that resonates with families and casual diners. However, service delays and occasional order errors during busy periods prevent consistent excellence, while attentiveness varies significantly depending on staffing levels. The BYOB setup and comfortable patio seating enhance the experience, making it a solid choice for laid-back Maui dining without the reliability of higher-rated establishments.
Set along South Kihei Road, Black Rock Pizza brings a laid-back island vibe with a breezy lanai and a casual, BYOB setup. Service ranges from warm and attentive to stretched-thin on busy nights—one diner said the team was "kind and hustling, but we still waited." When it clicks, the experience feels friendly and neighborhood with pies flying out of the ovens. In the kitchen, the approach leans creative and island-influenced rather than old-school Italian. Expect inventive toppings like kalua pork with hoisin BBQ on the Hoi Boi, or spicy chorizo and jalapeno on the Killa-uea. The crust earns frequent praise for its crisp-chewy balance, though a few guests report soft centers during rushes. Vegan and gluten-free options go beyond token gestures, with things like vegan cauliflower wings and GF desserts. Families do well here thanks to approachable choices—pepperoni, BBQ chicken, and garlic breadsticks are kid magnets. There is no kids menu called out, but the menu has plenty of familiar items, and patio seating makes it easy with strollers and sandy feet. If your crew prefers simple flavors, stick to classic builds and skip the spicier fusion pies.
Area: Beach-town strip with casual eateries serving tourists and locals; relaxed vibe near condos and resorts.
Safety: Generally safe, busy roadway frontage; occasional maintenance complaints in reviews but typical foot traffic.
Nearby: Near South Kihei Road condos, beaches, groceries; convenient for takeout to nearby resorts.
Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →