Seemor
St Paul › St Paul › Forepaugh's Restaurant
Forepaugh's RestaurantB+
276 Exchange St S, St Paul, MN 55102
· American restaurant, Italian restaurant, Restaurant
· St Paul
Romantic, historic-mansion setting with creative, high-end American-Italian plates; superb on great nights but inconsistency, slow pacing, and small portions can dent value.
Why this grade
Forepaugh's delivers solid neighborhood dining anchored by exceptional setting appeal in a restored Victorian mansion and strong wine and menu guidance. However, inconsistent food execution—ranging from celebrated beef Wellington to underseasoned dishes—and slow pacing on busy nights prevent a higher grade. Best suited for special occasions where ambiance matters more than speed or portion generosity.
One caveat: Service pacing can be very slow at peak times; expect a leisurely meal
What to order here
- Forepaugh's Beef Wellington
- Ribeye au Poivre
- Shellfish Rigatoni Alla Chitarra
What stands out
- Atmospheric mansion rooms that feel private
- Attentive servers who know pairings and history
- Signature classics like beef Wellington and lamb chops
Opening Hours
Monday
Tuesday15:30–22:30
Wednesday15:30–22:30
Thursday15:30–22:30
Friday15:30–22:30
Saturday15:30–22:30
Sunday
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →