Huge Tuscan-style schiacciata sandwiches with standout bread and creative fillings; lines, limited seating, and occasional service hiccups are the tradeoff.
All'Antico Vinaio delivers exceptional bread quality and generous, shareable portions that justify its Instagram fame and Florence pedigree, but inconsistent filling quantities and isolated food safety concerns prevent higher marks. Fast counter service and ingredient-driven Tuscan flavors appeal to sandwich enthusiasts willing to navigate tight quarters and lines near Times Square.
One caveat: Seating is minimal; most diners take away or stand