Seemor

ANDIAMO PIZZAC

115 E 23rd St, New York, NY 10010 · Pizza restaurant · Flatiron District

Solid slice shop with broad variety and strong service, but quality is inconsistent and pricing runs high for the category.

Why this grade

Andiamo Pizza delivers friendly counter service and maintains a clean, modern space, but inconsistent slice quality—particularly variable crust texture and reheating—undermines reliability. Recent feedback shows persistent concerns with doneness and temperature, while moderate authenticity concerns due to reported review incentives create uncertainty in the overall assessment. Worth visiting if nearby, but not a destination worth a special trip.

One caveat: Inconsistent execution on crispness and temperature across slices

What to order here

What stands out

Opening Hours

Monday09:00–04:00 Tuesday09:00–04:00 Wednesday09:00–05:00 Thursday09:00–04:00 Friday09:00–05:00 Saturday09:00–05:00 Sunday09:00–04:00
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →