Seemor
ANDIAMO PIZZACProceed Cautiously
115 E 23rd St, New York, NY 10010
· Pizza restaurant
· 4.6/5 Google (809 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Solid slice shop with broad variety and strong service, but quality is inconsistent and pricing runs high for the category.
Why it gets a C for overall quality
Andiamo Pizza delivers friendly counter service and maintains a clean, modern space, but inconsistent slice quality—particularly variable crust texture and reheating—undermines reliability. Recent feedback shows persistent concerns with doneness and temperature, while moderate authenticity concerns due to reported review incentives create uncertainty in the overall assessment. Worth visiting if nearby, but not a destination worth a special trip.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels clean and modern, a counter-service slice shop where staff are often praised as friendly and quick. Expect a steady flow of locals and visitors near Gramercy Theatre. The cooking leans classic NY-style with Grandma and Sicilian squares, vodka and white pies, plus vegan and gluten-free options. The culinary approach is familiar and comfort-first: when reheated well, slices can be crisp and satisfying, but reviews note inconsistency in doneness and temperature. Families will find plenty of kid-friendly choices: cheese and pepperoni slices, pasta like spaghetti marinara, and mozzarella sticks. No kids menu, but the basics are covered. Consider ordering whole pies for predictable quality and asking for well-done reheats on slices.
At a Glance
- Exceptionally broad menu for a slice shop, including vegan and gluten-free pies
- Clean space and consistently friendly counter staff
- Inconsistent slice reheating and crust texture
- Pricing feels high for portion size to some diners
- Moderate authenticity concerns due to incentive allegations and templated replies
What Sets It Apart
- broad_dietary_pizza_options
- high_owner_responsiveness
- central_flatiron_location
What People Love
- Friendly, efficient counter service
- Clean, modern environment
- Classic NY flavors when cooked crisp
- Lots of veggie and specialty slice choices
Points of Concern
- Inconsistent execution on crispness and temperature across slices
- Several value complaints about small slices at higher prices
- A few isolated food safety and freshness allegations amid many clean mentions
- Review patterns show signs of potential manipulation (incentive claims, templated replies) which may not reflect typical diner experience
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$20-$30 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- For gluten-free: 14 inch Gluten Free Pizza $25.95 as baseline
- For vegan: Vegan Cheese Pie $28.00; add a veggie slice if available
- Value play: Share an 18 inch NY Style Cheese $28 among 2-3
Perfect For
- Quick pre-show bite near Gramercy Theatre
- Groups with mixed dietary needs (vegan/gluten-free)
- Casual lunch between errands
- Solo slice-and-go stop
Location Insights
Area: Busy Flatiron/Gramercy corridor with office workers, visitors, and pre-show crowds near Gramercy Theatre.
Safety: Well-lit, high foot traffic, generally safe day and evening with typical Midtown vigilance.
Nearby: Near Friends Experience, Gramercy Theatre, offices, shops; strong daytime and event-driven demand.
GramercyGramercy offers a refined dining scene with a mix of upscale restaurants, trendy cafes, and classic New York eateries. The area is characterized by a quiet, residential feel with tree-lined streets, attracting diners who appreciate a blend of sophistication and casual charm.
NoMadNoMad (North of Madison Square Park) is a trendy sub-area known for its boutique hotels, innovative dining concepts, and lively nightlife. It draws a crowd interested in contemporary cuisine and stylish atmospheres, making it a hotspot for food enthusiasts.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday09:00–04:00
Tuesday09:00–04:00
Wednesday09:00–05:00
Thursday09:00–04:00
Friday09:00–05:00
Saturday09:00–05:00
Sunday09:00–04:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →