Seemor
Black Horse PubBWorth Trying
568 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
· Pub, Bar, New American restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (814 reviews)
Reservations · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Neighborhood pub with lively game-day energy, crowd-pleasing bar food, and variable service; great for sports and groups, less ideal for those seeking polished hospitality.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Black Horse Pub earns its grade through strong food quality in burgers, wings, and nachos, plus excellent spaciousness that handles groups well. However, inconsistent execution—occasional overcooked fish and soggy quesadillas—and uneven service during peak matches prevent higher standing. It's a reliable local favorite for sports and comfort food, not a destination restaurant.
Restaurant Summary
The scene is a neighborhood pub where sports take center stage and the staff often know regulars by name. Expect lively game-night energy, TV channel changes on request, and plates of wings and burgers sliding out fast. A diner summed it up: "Felt like a local Cheers, and they remembered my drink." Occasional reports note uneven service during peak matches. The cooking leans comfort-first pub grub rather than chefly flourishes: juicy burgers, crisp wings, piled nachos, and crowd-pleasing tacos and burritos. Most plates land right; a few misses pop up with overcooked fish or soggy quesadillas when slammed. It is best for fans wanting solid food with wall-to-wall sports rather than a polished, quiet meal. Families do fine here earlier in the evening. Kids will recognize burgers and fries, mac and cheese, mozzarella sticks, and simple salads. There is no formal kids menu noted, but the basics are friendly and shareable; come before big games for an easier, quieter experience.
At a Glance
- Juicy burgers, crisp wings, and hefty nachos draw repeat visits
- Great for sports with flexible TV switching and space for groups
- Service can slow or feel inattentive during packed events
- A few dish misses (overcooked fish, soggy quesadilla) reported
- Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food
What Sets It Apart
- live_game_switching
- large_group_handling
- neighborhood_regulars_culture
What People Love
- Feeling like a regular in a welcoming pub
- Game-day atmosphere with screens everywhere
- Burgers that are juicy and sizable
- Wings with well-balanced buffalo sauce
- Quick TV changes to catch the right game
Points of Concern
- Service inconsistency appears during peak sports nights; some reports of slow or dismissive interactions
- A few food execution issues (overcooked fish, soggy quesadilla) amid otherwise solid pub fare
- Expect noise and crowding during finals or major matches
- Limited options for conservative palates or picky eaters
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$36-48 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Vegetarians: Veggie burger, mac and cheese, mozzarella sticks, Monster Nachos without meat
- Seeking value: Burger with fries at $13 is the strongest deal
- Groups: Share Monster Nachos plus wings before mains
Perfect For
- Watching a big match with friends
- Casual weeknight dinner and a beer
- Group hangouts up to 10 without fuss
- Solo bite at the bar before or after a game
Location Insights
Area: Residential, family-friendly Park Slope corridor with active nightlife on Fifth Ave and steady game-day crowds.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked avenue with consistent foot traffic, especially evenings and weekends.
Nearby: Near other bars, casual eateries, boutiques; convenient for neighborhood meetups and sports viewing.
Park SlopeThe dining scene in Park Slope is eclectic and upscale-casual, featuring farm-to-table restaurants, cozy cafes, and diverse international cuisines. The neighborhood has a relaxed yet trendy atmosphere, attracting locals who appreciate quality food in a community-oriented setting.
South SlopeSouth Slope, near 5th Avenue, is known for its slightly more modern vibe with a growing number of trendy eateries, bars, and boutique shops. It is popular among younger residents seeking a lively but still neighborhood-focused dining experience.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday14:30–02:00
Tuesday14:30–02:00
Wednesday14:30–02:00
Thursday14:30–02:00
Friday14:30–03:00
Saturday09:30–03:00
Sunday11:00–12:00
Available: Reservations, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →