Seemor
Carragher'sB+Worth Trying
Basement Bar, 17 John St, New York, NY 10038
· Pub, Bar, Event venue
· 4.4/5 Google (2138 reviews)
Reservations · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Lively Irish-leaning sports bar and Liverpool FC hub with solid pub grub, great match-day atmosphere, and some policy missteps on cover charges and reservations.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Carragher's delivers solid pub dining with strong food quality in burgers, Irish breakfast, and classic appetizers, backed by attentive, friendly service that shines during match days. However, quality variation during peak and holiday service prevents a higher grade, and the venue functions primarily as a sports-first destination rather than a culinary destination. It's an excellent choice for game-day atmosphere and reliable pub fare, but not a premier dining establishment.
Restaurant Summary
A basement-level Irish-leaning sports bar in FiDi, Carragher's buzzes with scarves, screens, and Liverpool memorabilia. On match days the room turns electric, with guests saying service feels warm and attentive and pub staples hit the spot. One fan summed it up: "Looked like a regular bar from the street, but inside it felt like home on game day." However, there are some review authenticity concerns suggesting certain reviews may be solicited or influenced. The cooking leans classic pub comfort more than culinary fireworks, with burgers and an Irish breakfast drawing the loudest cheers. Think solid fry-cook execution, speedy plates when the room hums, and the occasional flourish among appetizers. It is a destination to watch the game first and eat second—ideal if you want familiar flavors, a pint, and big-match energy rather than fine-dining polish. Families do fine here: kids are welcome, there is a children's menu with simple pasta, and classics like fries, chicken fingers, and burgers travel well for younger palates. It gets crowded and loud during marquee matches, so earlier breakfasts or non-peak games are best if you want a calmer family outing.
At a Glance
- Lively match-day atmosphere with friendly staff
- Solid pub staples (burgers, Irish breakfast, wings) and good portions
- Event-day cover charges and reservation policies frustrate some guests
- Service missteps during peak/holiday events
- Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food
What Sets It Apart
- dedicated_liverpool_fc_hub
- hearty_irish_breakfasts
- large_sports_viewing_space
What People Love
- Feeling like part of a fan community
- Quick drinks and fast pub food on busy days
- Reasonable prices for downtown NYC
- Memorabilia-filled space that sets the mood
Points of Concern
- Event-day cover charges, deposits, and early arrival rules can catch visitors off guard
- TV allocation and streaming rights conflicts sometimes disrupt viewing plans
- Holiday and peak-event service can slip with delays or errors
- Review patterns show signs of potential manipulation (extreme positives and negatives, marketing-style language) which may not reflect typical diner experience
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$38-52 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- For vegetarians: Garden Omelette or Baked Honey & Garlic Cauliflower
- For lighter bite: Lobster Bisque and a shared appetizer
- For kids: Children menu pasta with butter or tomato sauce
Perfect For
- Watching a Premier League or college game with friends
- Casual group meetups before or after exploring Lower Manhattan
- Hearty Irish breakfast on early match days
- Traveling supporters seeking a Liverpool FC hub
Location Insights
Area: Busy downtown Financial District spot serving office workers, locals, and visiting sports fans; nightlife spikes on match days.
Safety: Generally safe, high foot traffic near transit; typical late-night urban bustle.
Nearby: Near Fulton St transit hub, City Hall, and Seaport; heavy office and tourist mix.
Financial DistrictThe Financial District has transformed from a strictly business area into a vibrant neighborhood with a diverse dining scene ranging from casual bars to upscale restaurants. The social atmosphere is a blend of daytime business crowds and an increasingly lively nightlife, attracting both locals and visitors. Safety and accessibility have improved significantly, making it a popular spot for after-work gatherings and weekend outings.
South Street SeaportSouth Street Seaport is a historic waterfront area within the Financial District known for its maritime heritage, cobblestone streets, and a cluster of bars and restaurants. It offers a more relaxed and scenic dining environment compared to the busier core of the Financial District, popular for casual dining and socializing with views of the East River.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday10:00–02:00
Tuesday10:00–02:00
Wednesday10:00–04:00
Thursday10:00–04:00
Friday10:00–04:00
Saturday10:00–04:00
Sunday10:00–02:00
Available: Reservations, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →