Seemor

Carragher'sB+

Basement Bar, 17 John St, New York, NY 10038 · Pub, Bar, Event venue · Financial District

Lively Irish-leaning sports bar and Liverpool FC hub with solid pub grub, great match-day atmosphere, and some policy missteps on cover charges and reservations.

The verdict

Carragher's delivers solid pub dining with strong food quality in burgers, Irish breakfast, and classic appetizers, backed by attentive, friendly service that shines during match days. However, quality variation during peak and holiday service prevents a higher grade, and the venue functions primarily as a sports-first destination rather than a culinary destination. It's an excellent choice for game-day atmosphere and reliable pub fare, but not a premier dining establishment.

One caveat: Event-day cover charges, deposits, and early arrival rules can catch visitors off guard

What to order

What diners say

Opening Hours

Monday10:00–02:00 Tuesday10:00–02:00 Wednesday10:00–04:00 Thursday10:00–04:00 Friday10:00–04:00 Saturday10:00–04:00 Sunday10:00–02:00
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →