Seemor
Club MacanudoBWorth Trying
26 E 63rd St, New York, NY 10065
· Bar, American restaurant, Lounge
· 4.5/5 Google (714 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Classic Upper East Side cigar lounge with polished ambiance, solid comfort-food menu, steep cigar pricing, and service that ranges from gracious to brusque.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Club Macanudo delivers a polished lounge experience anchored by exceptional setting appeal—warm wood paneling, refined Upper East Side charm, and impressive ventilation for a cigar environment. Solid food quality with signature comfort dishes and truffles pairs well with knowledgeable bartenders, though inconsistent execution and occasional service delays prevent a higher grade. Best suited for cigar enthusiasts and adult diners seeking classic lounge atmosphere rather than culinary distinction.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels warm and wood-paneled, with low lighting, leather chairs, and that polished Upper East Side hush that still hums when the playlist and chatter pick up. One guest summed it up as “classic, comfortable, and refined,” while another praised how staff kept ashtrays spotless and the ventilation impressively clear for a cigar crowd. On the plate, expect elevated lounge comfort—sliders, wings, calamari, steaks, and a few global touches like tuna tartare and blackened tuna over soba. The cooking leans classic and satisfying rather than showy, and the signature warm chocolate truffles are a quiet hit. Drinks are well made, and the bar team can be knowledgeable and welcoming, though a few reports note inconsistencies and one whiskey mispour incident. Families should skip this one. The environment is a dedicated cigar lounge with a per-person minimum, a strong bar focus, and no kids' options. Even with solid ventilation, smoke and the adult vibe make it unsuitable for children, so plan accordingly.
At a Glance
- Classic lounge ambiance with excellent ventilation and polished design
- Signature desserts and solid lounge bites fit the setting
- Cigar prices are significant markups over retail
- Hostess interactions and reservation delays reported by some guests
- Dedicated cigar environment; not suitable for families or smoke-sensitive diners
What Sets It Apart
- dedicated_cigar_experience_with_ventilation
- classic_upper_east_side_lounge_atmosphere
- member_lockers_and_walk_in_minimum_structure
What People Love
- Old world charm and wood-lined room
- Ventilation that keeps smoke manageable
- Attentive bartenders who guide cigar and drink choices
- Warm chocolate truffles as a signature finish
- Comfortable seating for lingering conversations
Points of Concern
- Cigar pricing is far above retail; multiple guests call out specific markup examples
- Inconsistent service at the door and hostess stand; some felt rushed or unwelcome
- Reservation delays on busy nights can stretch well past booking times
- Isolated but serious reports: whiskey mispour and one pest sighting
- Review patterns show polarized experiences; weigh detailed critiques alongside many detailed praises
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$62-$88 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Start with calamari or wings, share sliders, then steak or chicken saltimbocca; finish with the warm truffles.
- If cigar markup is a concern, focus spend on cocktails and desserts while keeping cigar selection modest.
Perfect For
- Post-dinner cigar and nightcap
- Client entertaining in a classic setting
- Date night with a lounge vibe
- Solo unwind at the bar with a cigar
Location Insights
Area: Upscale Upper East Side block near Madison Park Avenue retail; attracts business meetings and date nights.
Safety: Well-lit, high foot traffic, generally very safe into late evening.
Nearby: Close to luxury boutiques, galleries, and hotels; convenient for shoppers and business travelers.
Upper East SideThe Upper East Side offers a refined dining scene with a mix of high-end restaurants, classic New York eateries, and casual cafes. The atmosphere is generally upscale and quiet, catering to well-heeled locals and visitors seeking quality and exclusivity.
Lenox HillLenox Hill is a sub-area known for its proximity to major medical centers and luxury residential buildings, featuring a mix of casual and upscale dining options that serve both local residents and hospital visitors.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday16:00–00:00
Tuesday16:00–01:00
Wednesday16:00–01:00
Thursday16:00–02:00
Friday16:00–02:00
Saturday16:00–02:00
Sunday16:00–22:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →