Seemor
Fulton Fish Co.A-Worth Trying
96 South St, New York, NY 10038
· Seafood restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (106 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Polished raw bar and seafood inside Tin Building delivering very fresh oysters and crowd-pleasing plates, with inconsistent service and premium pricing.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
Fulton Fish Co. delivers solid A-grade performance anchored by exceptional oyster quality and raw bar execution paired with outstanding waterfront market-hall ambiance. However, inconsistent cooked dishes and variable service pacing prevent grade A territory—order confidently from the raw bar and let the oysters lead, but approach cooked plates with caution. A worthwhile destination for seafood lovers willing to navigate occasional execution gaps.
Restaurant Summary
Set within the Tin Building, this spot pairs a raw bar glow with a market-hall buzz that feels warm and bustling. Diners rave about pristine oysters and friendly bartenders, with one guest noting, "the oysters made up for last night elsewhere." The setting reads gorgeous and lively, though a few report slow check-ins at peak times. The cooking leans elevated seafood with classic comfort—think fish and chips, lobster rolls, and grilled octopus—punctuated by modern touches like crispy rice with sea trout and uni crudo. The raw bar is the clear headliner; cooked plates can shine but sides and execution vary, so order where the kitchen shows confidence and let the oysters lead. Families do fine here if they enjoy seafood. There is fish and chips, lobster rolls, and simple sides for less adventurous eaters, while salads and toasts help non-seafood diners. No explicit kids menu is noted, so plan to share approachable dishes and skip the pricier raw bar for younger palates.
At a Glance
- Exceptionally fresh oysters and strong raw bar
- Stylish Tin Building setting with lively counter seating
- Service pacing and attentiveness vary by section and time
- Premium pricing with sides that can underwhelm
- Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food
What Sets It Apart
- showcase_raw_bar
- polished_market_hall_setting
- chef_program_influence
What People Love
- Briny, impeccably fresh oysters
- Friendly, knowledgeable bartenders and servers
- The chic, European-feeling market ambiance
- A standout crispy rice dish that surprises
Points of Concern
- Service can be slow or inattentive during busy periods; a few guests report long waits for menus or refills
- Cooked sides like potato wedges can be bland compared to the fish
- Pricing is genuinely expensive ($24+ mains; premium for raw bar)
- Creative/fusion accents may challenge conservative palates
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$55-$80 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Lead with oysters and a crisp white wine; add Sea Trout Crispy Rice to share; finish with a simple salad to balance richness.
Perfect For
- Pre-show oysters and wine at the counter
- Date night with a seafood focus
- Out-of-town visitors exploring the Seaport
- Solo bite with a half dozen oysters
Location Insights
Area: Revitalized waterfront market-hall setting drawing locals and visitors; polished, lifestyle-focused vibe.
Safety: Well-trafficked Seaport area with active retail and dining; generally safe and maintained.
Nearby: Inside Tin Building food hall by Jean-Georges; near Pier 17, East River views, ferries and events.
Financial DistrictThe Financial District is characterized by its dense concentration of office buildings, historic landmarks, and a growing residential population. Dining options range from quick lunch spots catering to office workers to upscale restaurants and casual eateries serving tourists and locals alike. The area is busy during weekdays but quieter in the evenings and weekends, with a mix of business and leisure dining atmospheres.
South Street SeaportSouth Street Seaport is a historic waterfront area within the Financial District known for its maritime heritage, shopping, and dining. It attracts tourists and locals seeking casual dining with views of the East River, offering a relaxed atmosphere distinct from the busier financial core.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday12:00–22:00
Tuesday12:00–22:00
Wednesday12:00–22:00
Thursday12:00–22:00
Friday12:00–22:00
Saturday12:00–22:00
Sunday12:00–22:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →