Seemor
George KeeleyBWorth Trying
485 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
· Pub, Bar, American restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (584 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Craft-beer focused Upper West Side pub with reliable bar eats, lively game-day energy, and generally friendly bartenders, though service can be inconsistent and a few nickel-and-dime charges have irked guests.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
George Keeley delivers solid neighborhood pub performance anchored by reliable pub staples—burgers and fish and chips earn consistent praise—and fair Manhattan pricing with thoughtful touches like free popcorn. However, service inconsistency ranging from friendly bartenders to indifferent moments and occasional quality variation prevent a higher grade. The cozy, modern interior on Amsterdam Avenue appeals to locals and game-day crowds but lacks destination-level distinction.
Restaurant Summary
A neighborhood pub that leans into craft beer, George Keeley feels warm and bustling most nights, especially during big games. Guests talk about rotating taps, free popcorn, and bartenders who will happily pour a taste before you commit. One diner put it simply: "Strong drinks, fair prices, and a place you can settle in for the match." The room reads cozy and modern rather than flashy, and it can get loud when the crowd builds. Cooking here favors comfort over fireworks: burgers, wings, fish and chips, tenders, and a chicken sando. The approach is classic pub fare that delivers more often than not—crisp fish, juicy burgers, and portions that satisfy, even if the fries sometimes feel a bit skimpy. Come for beer variety and game-day camaraderie; order the staples and you will likely leave content. Families do fine here thanks to kid-approved staples like cheeseburgers, chicken tenders, and fries. Teens especially seem happy with burgers and fish and chips. No clear kids menu was mentioned, but the straightforward offerings keep choices easy. Expect lively energy rather than quiet dining, so earlier hours may suit younger children best.
At a Glance
- Deep rotating craft beer list with fair Manhattan pricing
- Solid pub staples—burgers and fish and chips earn repeat praise
- Service inconsistency from great bartenders to no acknowledgment at times
- Isolated reports of small extra charges and tip confrontations
- Cozy interior and lively game-day atmosphere
What Sets It Apart
- rotating_craft_beer_list
- complimentary_popcorn
- neighborhood_game_day_hub
What People Love
- Rotating tap list and samples before ordering
- Complimentary salty popcorn
- Crispy fish and satisfying burgers
- Lively but welcoming neighborhood vibe
Points of Concern
- Service can swing from attentive to unresponsive depending on shift and crowd
- Some guests reported condiment or hot water charges they did not expect
- One account of bartender joining patrons in mocking a non-drinker, harming trust
- Pricing is Manhattan-normal but can feel high if food lands average
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$35-$48 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Start with Buffalo Wings or GK Jalapenos, then go GK Burger Ya; pair with a $10-ish rotating draft.
- Fish Fingers and Chips are reliable; consider an extra side if you want more fries.
Perfect For
- Watching a big game with friends
- Casual burger-and-beer night
- Solo pint at the bar off-peak
- Pre- or post-neighborhood meetup on the UWS
Location Insights
Area: Residential Upper West Side corridor with casual pubs, family traffic, and game-day crowds.
Safety: Well-trafficked and generally safe; active evenings with steady foot traffic.
Nearby: Near brownstones, shops, and other bars on Amsterdam Ave; convenient for neighborhood meetups and sports viewing.
Upper West SideThe Upper West Side boasts a diverse dining scene ranging from classic New York delis to high-end restaurants. The social atmosphere is relaxed yet sophisticated, attracting locals who appreciate quality food and a neighborhood feel. It is safe, accessible, and popular among both residents and visitors exploring nearby museums and parks.
Lincoln SquareLincoln Square is a cultural hub within the Upper West Side, home to Lincoln Center and several theaters. The dining scene here includes upscale restaurants, casual cafes, and spots catering to pre- and post-show crowds, creating a lively and arts-focused atmosphere.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday16:00–00:00
Tuesday16:00–00:00
Wednesday16:00–00:00
Thursday14:00–02:00
Friday14:00–02:00
Saturday12:00–02:00
Sunday12:00–00:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →