Lively Greenpoint spot for creative New American plates, a standout smash burger, and strong cocktails; service can be inconsistent and prices lean high for drinks.
Leroy's delivers solid neighborhood dining with reliable food quality anchored by a much-loved smash burger and creative comfort sides, supported by a warm, social bar atmosphere and strong repeat customer loyalty. However, inconsistent execution during peak service—particularly slow pacing and occasional inattentiveness—prevents the restaurant from reaching higher territory, while drink pricing feels steep relative to portions. It's a worthwhile destination for North Brooklyn diners seeking elevated comfort food and cocktails in a lively setting, but lacks the consistency and distinction of top-tier neighborhood favorites.
One caveat: Service inconsistencies: slower greets and missed check-ins on busy nights (recurring but not universal)