Seemor

Maggie Reilly'sBWorth Trying

Name: Maggie Reilly's
Address: 340 9th Ave, New York, NY 10001, New York, United States
Rating: 4.5

340 9th Ave, New York, NY 10001 · Irish pub, Restaurant · 4.5/5 Google (632 reviews)

Reservations · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Neighborhood Irish pub near MSG with friendly service, hearty classics, and a real kids menu; food quality ranges from solid to uneven and fish and chips can disappoint.

Why it gets a B for overall quality

Maggie Reilly's delivers solid neighborhood pub dining with attentive, friendly bartenders and reliable comfort food—burgers and mac and cheese shine—but inconsistent execution, especially with fish and chips, prevents higher grades. The convenient Midtown location, generous portions, and welcoming owner presence make it a worthwhile stop before events or for casual dining, though it lacks the distinction of premier local establishments.

Restaurant Summary

Steps from Penn and the Garden, this spot feels like a cozy neighborhood pub that regulars swear by and travelers stumble into before a show. Bartenders are often praised for never letting a glass run dry. One diner summed it up: "Comfortable room, friendly faces, and exactly what we needed before the concert." The cooking leans traditional Irish-American—think char broiled burgers, stews, and pies—more comfort than flash. When the kitchen is on, it hits the spot; burgers and mac shine, while fish and chips draw mixed notes, from satisfying to underdone. This is straightforward pub fare with generous portions rather than chefly theatrics. Families are welcome here. There is a real kids menu that includes juice and ice cream, plus easy wins like tenders, pasta, and burgers. If you have picky eaters, you will find options; adventurous kids can graze on nachos or a flatbread while adults handle the mains.

At a Glance

Friendly, attentive bartenders and welcoming owner presence
Big portions and fair prices for Midtown
Fish and chips quality varies; occasional undercooking reports
Service can lag during busy event windows
Legit kids menu with included dessert

What Sets It Apart

owner_present_hospitality
true_kids_menu_with_extras
pre_msg_convenience

What People Love

Warm, neighborhood vibe near big venues
Char broiled burgers that satisfy
Hearty mac and cheese and nachos to share
Bartenders who keep service easy and personable

Points of Concern

Fish and chips draw inconsistent feedback including small portions or undercooking
Occasional slow or indifferent service during peak times
Limited Irish whiskey variety noted by one guest
Pricing is Midtown-fair but still adds up with drinks

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost$40-$58 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

For vegetarians, try Veggie or Beyond Burger ($18) with fries or salad
Kids meals at $15 include juice and vanilla ice cream
Flatbreads offer a lighter shareable option (Margherita $16)

Perfect For

Pre-concert bite near MSG
Casual family dinner with kids
Solo meal at the bar with a solid burger
Group hangout with shareable apps and beers

Location Insights

Area: Mixed commercial block between Chelsea and Hudson Yards, foot traffic from MSG and Penn Station; after-work and pre-event crowd.

Safety: Generally busy and safe with steady foot traffic; typical Midtown late-evening urban feel.

Nearby: Near Madison Square Garden, Penn Station, and Hudson Yards; hotels and offices nearby drive pre/post event visits.

Hell's KitchenHell's Kitchen offers a vibrant dining scene with a variety of restaurants ranging from casual eateries to upscale dining. The neighborhood has a lively, urban atmosphere with a strong connection to the nearby Theater District, attracting both locals and tourists seeking diverse culinary experiences.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday10:00–04:00 Tuesday10:00–04:00 Wednesday10:00–04:00 Thursday10:00–04:00 Friday10:00–04:00 Saturday10:00–04:00 Sunday10:00–04:00

Available: Reservations, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →