Seemor

MayfieldB+Worth Trying

Name: Mayfield
Address: 688 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, Brooklyn, United States
Rating: 4.5

688 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238 · American restaurant, Hamburger restaurant · 4.5/5 Google (913 reviews)

Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Reliable neighborhood Modern American spot with standout oysters, burgers, and brunch, good cocktails, and occasional execution or service inconsistencies; prices run high for the experience.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

Mayfield delivers solid neighborhood dining with strong food quality highlighted by excellent oysters and burgers, though quality varies noticeably on fish and steaks. The warm, bustling atmosphere with an appreciated back patio and friendly service create a reliable local favorite, but pricing feels steep for the execution level and occasional misses prevent grade A territory. Worth visiting for brunch or cocktails if in Crown Heights.

Restaurant Summary

Mayfield reads as a neighborhood standby where the room feels warm and bustling, the bar turns out balanced classics, and servers usually keep things friendly. One diner summed it up: "A solid spot for oysters and a great burger," even if the scene can get a bit loud when full. The cooking leans Modern American comfort with polish—think juicy burgers and bright salads, well-executed steak tartare, and seasonal sides like Brussels with a kick. Not a temple of experimentation, but plates show care and decent ingredients. Hits are frequent, though a few misses pop up on fish and steaks, and prices can feel on the higher side for a casual evening. Families do fine here: burgers with fries, omelets, and French toast are easy wins, and the vibe is relaxed. No dedicated kids menu is listed, but brunch and sandwich staples suit younger eaters; adventurous dishes exist, yet there are always familiar options to fall back on.

At a Glance

Excellent oysters, burger, and steak tartare draw repeat visits
Lively neighborhood vibe with back patio and solid brunch
Prices and cocktail pours feel high for some diners
Inconsistent execution on fish and steak reported
One severe pest complaint and gritty oysters noted; isolated but serious

What Sets It Apart

wellfleet_oysters_focus
neighborhood_brunch_draw
back_patio_seating

What People Love

That first briny oyster with a crisp pour
A stacked burger with customizable toppings
Decadent mushroom ravioli starter
Unfussy, lively Brooklyn energy

Points of Concern

Pricing is genuinely high for a casual bistro (mains mid-to-high $20s; steak $49)
Occasional execution slips: overcooked fish or steak, salty seasoning
Service can be uneven, with slow kitchen or miscommunication at times
Review patterns show isolated food safety and cleanliness concerns that may not reflect typical visits

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost$48-66 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

Start with oysters and a shared Brussels; follow with the burger or cavatelli; finish with ricotta doughnuts. Brunch: Eggs Benedict or French toast with coffee.

Perfect For

Last-minute neighborhood date night
Casual brunch with friends
Oyster and cocktail hour
Solo bite at the bar

Location Insights

Area: Lively Crown Heights corridor with neighborhood bars, brunch spots, and evening foot traffic; mix of locals and visitors.

Safety: Generally safe with steady foot traffic; typical urban vigilance at night.

Nearby: Near Franklin Ave bar/restaurant strip, Prospect Park a walk away, residential blocks adjacent.

Prospect HeightsProspect Heights offers a dynamic dining scene with a blend of trendy restaurants, casual eateries, and classic Brooklyn establishments. The area is known for its cultural institutions, proximity to Prospect Park, and a lively yet community-oriented atmosphere.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday17:00–21:30 Tuesday17:00–21:30 Wednesday17:00–21:30 Thursday17:00–21:30 Friday17:00–22:30 Saturday17:00–22:30 Sunday11:00–21:30

Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →