Beloved UWS bagel institution reborn with fresh, chewy bagels, fast-moving lines, cash-first culture, and limited seating; quality is strong though old-guard loyalists note recipe differences and occasional service hiccups.
New Absolute Bagels delivers exceptional bagel quality with a crisp exterior and chewy interior that justifies its citywide reputation and loyal following. However, cleanliness and hygiene concerns combined with inconsistent execution across batches and cramped, uncomfortable seating prevent a higher grade. The fast service and fair pricing make it a solid neighborhood choice for quick breakfast, but operational reliability issues hold it back from competing with top-tier bagel destinations.
One caveat: Cleanliness and glove-changing practices noted by multiple reviews; interior can feel run-down during rush