Polished West Village Italian with standout carbonara and lively ambiance; great energy and many hits, but service inconsistency, reservation friction, and pricey specials temper the glow.
Olio e Più delivers solid A-grade performance through exceptional food quality—particularly the celebrated carbonara and handmade pastas—paired with appealing West Village charm and warm, attentive service. However, inconsistent execution and tight seating prevent the higher tier; peak-hour service friction and occasional kitchen lapses keep it competitive with respected neighborhood favorites rather than among the region's finest Italian destinations.
One caveat: Service inconsistency: occasional long waits to be greeted and mixed hostess experiences (medium frequency)