Seemor

PopUp BagelsB+

139 E 57th St, New York, NY 10022 · Bagel shop, Bag shop, Caterer

Hot, rip-and-dip bagels with creative schmears; delicious but strictly multi-bagel takeaway format and no single-bagel sales.

Why this grade

PopUp Bagels delivers exceptional bagel quality—hot, fresh, and perfectly textured—with strong service warmth that creates a welcoming Midtown experience. Severe space constraints and occasional clarity gaps prevent a higher grade, but the focused execution on what matters most—fresh bagels and rotating schmears—makes this a solid neighborhood destination worth visiting for quality grab-and-go breakfast.

One caveat: Minimum order policy frustrates solo diners and casual samplers

What to order here

What stands out

Opening Hours

Monday07:00–16:00 Tuesday07:00–16:00 Wednesday07:00–16:00 Thursday07:00–16:00 Friday07:00–16:00 Saturday07:00–16:00 Sunday07:00–16:00
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →