Cozy Tribeca tavern with standout Alidoro sandwiches and a neighborhood-bar vibe, but service can be brusque and late-night hours appear inconsistent.
Puffy's Tavern delivers solid neighborhood appeal anchored by excellent Alidoro sandwiches with quality ingredients and bread, but inconsistent service—ranging from warmly attentive to notably rude—undermines the experience. The classic corner location with wrap-around seating offers genuine charm, yet crowding and unpredictable door policies prevent this from becoming a reliable destination. Worth visiting for the sandwiches and local vibe, but expect variable execution.
One caveat: Service can be curt or defensive during busy periods; several reports cite rude interactions at the bar