Reservations · Outdoor seating
Stylish SoHo hotel bar with polished ambiance, strong cocktails, and a popular afternoon tea; food quality is good but inconsistent, prices are high, and recent service and hygiene complaints warrant caution.
The Crosby Bar delivers in atmosphere and cocktails but is held back by inconsistent food quality across dayparts and concerning hygiene practices that undermine confidence. The exceptional design and SoHo boutique charm make it worth visiting for afternoon tea or cocktails, but afternoon tea sandwiches frequently disappoint, and recent operational lapses suggest reliability concerns that prevent a higher grade.
Inside a colorful SoHo boutique hotel, the room feels warm and bustling with art on every wall and custom china on the tables. Guests describe staff as warm and attentive when the room is humming, though some found slower, less polished moments. One diner summed up the vibe: "Every detail feels picked with care, from the plates to the flowers." However, there are some review authenticity concerns suggesting certain reviews may be solicited or influenced. The kitchen focuses on elevated comfort—think burgers and beef bourguignon alongside miso-glazed fish and yuzu-dressed tuna—more classic polish than theatrics, with cocktails that over-deliver. Afternoon tea is a draw for visitors and locals alike, but feedback divides: scones and setting shine while sandwiches sometimes arrive dry or tired. If you want creative flourishes without a science project, this is an elegant hotel choice at SoHo prices. Families will find accessible plates like the grass fed burger, fries, and simple pastas, plus chocolate cake and cheesecake for dessert. There is no listed kids menu, and the room can feel crowded at peak times. For picky eaters, stick to familiar items; for adventurous teens, tuna tartare or the grains bowl could be fun. Afternoon tea can be magical for kids who enjoy ceremony, but manage expectations if sandwiches are a must.
Area: Trendy SoHo block with boutique hotels, luxury retail, and creative offices; draws stylish locals and visitors.
Safety: Well-trafficked, generally safe, strong daytime and evening footfall; hotel setting feels secure.
Nearby: Near Balthazar, designer shops, galleries, and NoHo/Nolita edges; heavy shopping and nightlife crowd.
Available: Reservations, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →