Seemor

The GafCWorth Trying

Name: The Gaf
Address: 1696 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10128, New York, United States
Rating: 4.6

1696 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10128 · Pub, Irish pub, Bar · 4.6/5 Google (162 reviews)

Reservations · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Neighborhood Irish pub with friendly bartenders, darts and a backyard patio; no food, solid drinks, and lively game nights.

Why it gets a C for overall quality

The Gaf delivers solid neighborhood pub appeal through exceptional bartender attentiveness and reliable execution, with properly poured Guinness and a welcoming backyard patio that regulars clearly love. However, the complete absence of food service fundamentally limits its scope compared to full-service establishments, and modest ambiance keeps it a local hangout rather than a destination. For what it is—a friendly, efficient Irish pub with darts and trivia—it performs admirably.

Restaurant Summary

A neighborhood Irish pub with a warm, low-key vibe, The Gaf wins people over with friendly bartenders, TVs for the game, and a backyard patio. One guest put it simply: "reliable neighborhood stop" where the staff keeps things smooth, even when it is busy. Expect darts and trivia to kick the energy up. The drinks are classic rather than flashy, with properly poured Guinness, solid cocktails like a clean gin martini, and cheap pitchers for groups. Think dependable pours, a jukebox that leans upbeat, and a crowd that skews local. It is a straight-shooting pub: no frills, friendly faces, and prices that make sense for the UES. Families should note there is no food service and the focus is adult hangouts with darts, sports, and late-night energy. If you need kid-friendly meals or a wide non-alcohol lineup, this spot may not fit; older teens might still enjoy the back patio vibe during quieter hours.

At a Glance

Friendly, efficient bartenders remembered by name
Properly poured Guinness and solid classic cocktails
Darts, trivia nights, backyard patio add to the hang
No food service at all
Occasional rude or tip-sensitive bartender interaction reported

What Sets It Apart

proper_guinness_pour
backyard_patio_on_ues
active_darts_and_trivia_scene

What People Love

Welcoming neighborhood vibe
Bartenders who keep things moving
Back patio hangouts
Cheap pitchers for groups
Guinness poured right

Points of Concern

No kitchen; plan to eat elsewhere before or after
Occasional service hiccups including a rude interaction and outside seating self-service
Gets crowded and louder during games and trivia, with tighter space
Limited accommodation for dietary needs since there is no food menu

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average CostUSD20-35 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

Based on reviews, stick to Guinness, classic cocktails, and pitchers; eat elsewhere since there is no kitchen.

Perfect For

Watching a game with friends
Casual after-work pints
Darts or trivia night
Pre- or post-Met Museum drinks

Location Insights

Area: Residential Upper East Side corridor with steady foot traffic and sports-bar demand.

Safety: Generally safe, well-lit streets and active sidewalks into late evening.

Nearby: Near Second Ave subway, apartments, casual bars; convenient pre- and post-game hangout.

YorkvilleYorkville offers a quieter, more residential atmosphere compared to the rest of the Upper East Side, with a growing number of casual and mid-range dining spots alongside traditional eateries. The dining scene is approachable and family-friendly, reflecting the neighborhood's community-oriented vibe.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday14:00–04:00 Tuesday14:00–04:00 Wednesday14:00–04:00 Thursday14:00–04:00 Friday14:00–04:00 Saturday12:00–04:00 Sunday12:00–04:00

Available: Reservations, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →