Seemor
The Irish American PubB+Worth Trying
17 John St, New York, NY 10038
· Irish pub
· 4.4/5 Google (2213 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Casual downtown Irish pub with solid comfort food, lively game-day energy, and uneven service; good value by FiDi standards with broad, kid-friendly options.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
The Irish American Pub delivers reliable comfort food and a welcoming atmosphere competitive with the area's better neighborhood restaurants. Strong food quality in signature dishes like pot pie and French onion soup, paired with spacious seating ideal for groups and generous portions at reasonable prices, make it a solid choice for casual dining. However, inconsistent execution on fried items and occasional service gaps at the bar prevent it from reaching higher distinction.
Restaurant Summary
Down a flight of stairs in FiDi, this spot opens into a surprisingly big room with two bars, TVs, and a steady after‑work buzz that turns lively on game nights. Service swings from brisk to a bit scattered, but many describe it as friendly and attentive. One diner put it simply: "The fish was crisp, the fries were hot, and it felt like a proper pub night." Private events and watch parties make the space feel warm and bustling. The cooking leans classic Irish-American comfort: fish and chips, shepherds pie, chicken pot pie, French onion soup, and burgers. It is not chasing trends; think hearty portions at reasonable downtown prices. Most plates land well—wings, pot pie, and French dip get the nod—though there are occasional misses like soggy fish or dry lamb. Drinks are straightforward, with solid pours and an Irish whiskey presence. Families are welcome in the dining area, and there is a real kids menu at $14 that includes a drink and ice cream—mini pizza, pasta with butter or tomato, and chicken tenders. Staff enforces the no‑minors‑at‑the‑bar rule, but the menu makes this an easy pick for kids. If you need simple crowd‑pleasers, burgers, fries, and flatbread keep everyone happy.
At a Glance
- Hearty Irish-American comfort food with standout pot pie, wings, and French onion soup
- Spacious underground venue great for sports and groups
- Good value for FiDi with generous portions
- Service consistency varies, especially at the bar during rushes
- Occasional execution slips on fried items (soggy fish)
What Sets It Apart
- large_underground_space
- reliable_pub_classics
- strong_group_event_handling
What People Love
- Generous portions that feel like a deal downtown
- Classic comfort dishes done well
- Lively game-day energy
- Large, comfortable space that absorbs crowds
Points of Concern
- Service can be uneven with delays or brusque moments at the bar
- Quality dips reported on some visits (soggy fish, dry lamb)
- Bathrooms occasionally criticized; maintenance varies
- Billing or charge confusion reported in isolated cases
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$38-$55 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Pair French onion soup with a classic burger upgrade for a satisfying combo
- Kids: mini pizza or tenders plus ice cream is a dependable win
- Shareable starters like calamari or wings suit game-day tables
Perfect For
- Watching a game with a group
- Casual family dinner near Fulton/WTC
- After-work pints and pub bites
- Private lunches or informal events
Location Insights
Area: Busy Financial District block with office crowds, tourists, and after-work drinkers; basement-level pub space.
Safety: Generally safe, high foot traffic weekdays; typical downtown late-night urban realities.
Nearby: Near Fulton St transit hub, Wall St offices, hotels, and tourist points like the Seaport and WTC.
Financial DistrictThe Financial District is a bustling area dominated by corporate offices and historic landmarks, with a growing residential population. Dining options range from quick lunch spots catering to office workers to upscale restaurants and casual eateries serving tourists and locals alike. The atmosphere is a blend of weekday business energy and quieter evenings and weekends.
South Street SeaportSouth Street Seaport is a historic waterfront area within the Financial District known for its maritime heritage, shopping, and dining. It attracts tourists and locals looking for scenic views and casual dining experiences, often with seafood-focused menus and outdoor seating.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday10:00–02:00
Tuesday10:00–02:00
Wednesday10:00–04:00
Thursday10:00–04:00
Friday10:00–04:00
Saturday10:00–04:00
Sunday10:00–02:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →