Seemor
The Long Island BarB+Worth Trying
110 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201
· Cocktail bar, Bar, Restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (665 reviews)
Takeout
Retro-cool cocktail bar with a beloved double-patty burger and sharp vibes; great drinks and bar food, but expect crowds, strict service culture, and occasional attitude.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
The Long Island Bar delivers solid neighborhood dining anchored by strong food quality—a benchmark burger with dry-aged flavor and well-executed sides—and exceptional mid-century design that feels lovingly preserved. However, inconsistent burger doneness and variable cocktail execution prevent a higher grade, while service attitude can turn curt under pressure, limiting reliability. A respected local institution that delivers when conditions align, but falls short of the area's most consistently excellent dining destinations.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels warm and bustling in that mid-century way: terrazzo floors, neon glow, booths and a long bar humming with regulars. A guest summed it up: "Retro vibe, quick service, and drinks that taste like they were invented here." It is a neighborhood institution with tight-ship service when the gears mesh, but the volume and narrow aisle can make it feel bristly at peak. The cooking leans elevated comfort more than fancy: a juicy double-patty burger with tangy sauce, crisp fries, and snacky plates like fried cheese curds and deviled eggs. Cocktails skew classic and well-balanced when on form, with the White Negroni and martinis getting the most love; a few diners reported sweetness or mis-execution on off nights, so expectations should be calibrated to a serious bar first, kitchen second. Families can do fine earlier in the evening: burgers, fries, and simple salads are approachable, and there is a vegetarian tortilla española. That said, the space is tight, stroller navigation is tricky, and the crowd gets lively, so bring older kids or plan for off-peak visits if you need calmer energy.
At a Glance
- Benchmark neighborhood burger with dry-aged flavor
- Classic cocktails in a lovingly preserved retro setting
- Service attitude can feel strict or curt when crowded
- Inconsistent burger doneness and occasional long waits
- Groups face strict seating rules; back room policies enforced
What Sets It Apart
- meticulously_preserved_midcentury_bar
- double_patty_dry_aged_burger
- classic_cocktail_program
What People Love
- That first bite of the double-patty burger
- Nostalgic neon-and-terrazzo atmosphere
- Well-made martinis and White Negronis
- Snackable starters like cheese curds and deviled eggs
Points of Concern
- Service can be brusque at peak times; several reports of hostile tone
- Burger doneness and cocktail execution occasionally inconsistent
- Tight aisles and crowding reduce comfort in the main room
- Review patterns show signs of occasional heated incidents but not systemic manipulation
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$45-60 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- For vegetarians, choose Tortilla Española ($18) and a salad
- Seafood fans: Rainbow Trout ($26) with lemon miso butter
- Snackers: Deviled Eggs ($10) plus Fries ($10) with a martini
Perfect For
- Sliding into a bar seat for a martini and burger
- Low-key date night with classic vibes
- Catching up with a friend before a neighborhood stroll
- Solo bite at the bar with a great drink
Location Insights
Area: Charming brownstone corridor bridging Cobble Hill and Brooklyn Heights; popular with locals and cocktail seekers.
Safety: Well-lit, high foot traffic, generally safe even late; typical NYC urban awareness applies.
Nearby: Near Atlantic Ave shops, Montero’s karaoke, Brooklyn Bridge Park within a walk; strong neighborhood scene.
Brooklyn HeightsBrooklyn Heights is a historic and affluent neighborhood characterized by tree-lined streets, brownstone architecture, and a calm, upscale atmosphere. The dining scene here includes a mix of casual cafes, upscale restaurants, and trendy spots catering to both locals and visitors seeking quality and ambiance.
Fulton Ferry DistrictThe Fulton Ferry District is a small waterfront area within Brooklyn Heights known for its scenic views of Manhattan, historic significance, and a cluster of dining options ranging from casual eateries to refined restaurants. It attracts a mix of office workers during weekdays and tourists on weekends.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday
Tuesday17:00–00:00
Wednesday17:00–00:00
Thursday17:00–00:00
Friday17:00–00:00
Saturday14:00–00:00
Sunday14:00–00:00
Available: Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →