Seemor

The Pony BarB

1444 1st Ave, New York, NY 10021 · Pub, Bar & grill, Cocktail bar · Upper East Side

Neighborhood craft beer bar with friendly vibes, solid wings and bar bites, good for groups; service and cleanliness can be inconsistent at peak times.

The verdict

The Pony Bar delivers solid neighborhood bar performance anchored by strong food quality—particularly standout double-fried wings—and friendly, attentive service. However, inconsistent execution with occasional quality dips and isolated safety reports prevent grade A-level standing. It's a reliable local favorite worth visiting for craft beer and casual pub fare, though not a destination establishment.

One caveat: Service can lag when one server covers many tables

What to order

What diners say

Opening Hours

Monday15:00–00:00 Tuesday15:00–00:00 Wednesday15:00–00:00 Thursday15:00–01:00 Friday15:00–04:00 Saturday12:00–04:00 Sunday12:00–00:00
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →