Creative Cajun-meets-Italian slice shop with standout flavors and many vegan options; great for quick, tasty slices though service and reheated-slice consistency can vary.
Two Boots Pizza delivers bold Cajun-Italian flavors with creative signature pies and strong food quality, particularly praised for its thin, cornmeal-crunch crust. However, consistency challenges with reheated slices and mixed service warmth prevent a higher grade—visiting during peak hours or ordering fresh pies yields the best results. The convenient UWS location near Central Park and solid vegan options make it a worthwhile neighborhood stop for pizza enthusiasts, though not a destination establishment.
One caveat: Reheated slices can be dry or not hot enough during slow periods