Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Destination-level slices and whole pies with vegan options and stellar crust; limited seating and a mandatory 20% service fee polarize some diners.
Scottie's Pizza Parlor SE delivers exceptional food quality with crisp, snappy crusts and carefully balanced sauce that justify its destination reputation among slice enthusiasts. Consistency challenges—occasional burnt or dry pies during busy service—and severe seating limitations prevent a higher grade, though warm, attentive service and strong vegan options keep this a solid neighborhood favorite worth seeking out for quality pizza.
A tiny spot on Division with classic slice shop energy, Scottie’s draws steady lines for crisp-edged pies and a wall of pizza lore. Staff are often warm and patient, though the room is minuscule, so many grab-and-go. One diner said the crust "snaps in a satisfying way," while another praised the easygoing vibe. The cooking skews elevated traditional more than experimental: think an award-winning #1, a proper Margherita, and a grandma-style Defino square, plus seasonal riffs that keep regulars curious. Quality sauce, good cheese, and careful bakes define the highs, with occasional reports of overdone centers. Value feels fair for the quality, but note the mandatory service fee that some find frustrating. Families should know seating is scarce, but slices and simple pies make this kid-friendly food-wise. Plain, pepperoni, and stuffed-crust options suit many kids, and salads round things out. Vegan pies expand choices for mixed-diet groups, though plan to take it home if tables are full.
Area: Trendy inner Southeast corridor with indie eateries, bars, and boutiques; popular with locals and food-focused visitors.
Safety: Generally active and walkable; some reports of disruptive street activity affecting comfort for outdoor seating.
Nearby: Dense dining strip on SE Division; near residential streets, cafes, and small shops; high foot and bike traffic.
Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →