Reservations · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Modern barbecue spot with iconic meat donuts, strong steaks and smoked meats, lively vibe, and a real kids menu; a few reports of tough steaks and noise but overall a destination-worthy meal.
Dexter earns its A- grade through exceptional food quality—particularly the iconic meat donut and caramel short rib—paired with attentive, knowledgeable service. However, occasional inconsistency with steak execution and crowded seating during peak service prevent grade A territory. Strong neighborhood loyalty and creative modern barbecue approach make it competitive with the area's better dining destinations.
A neighborhood favorite with a lively, no-nonsense vibe, Dexter draws carnivores for smoky aromas, clinking glasses, and that first bite of the famous meat donut. One diner raved it was "mind-blowing," while servers offered easygoing, attentive care and spot-on drink recommendations. In the back room, though, a few guests noted it can be echoey at peak times. The cooking leans modern barbecue with creative flourishes: caramel short rib that slides off the bone, dry-aged burgers with real depth, and sides like bone marrow mash that steal the show. Expect bold, rich flavors over traditional pitmaster purity—more chef-driven smokehouse with clever fusion touches than purist BBQ. Most cuts hit the mark, though a handful of diners reported the odd tough steak or muted smoke on busy nights. For families, there is a genuine kids menu with cheeseburgers or chicken burgers plus fries, and plenty that kids will actually eat (fries, mash, burgers). Adventurous sides like sweet-sour cauliflower are there for curious palates, but classics keep the little ones happy. Prices are premium for the area, so plan accordingly.
Area: Inner-north suburban high street with creative eateries, casual pubs, and mixed residential crowd.
Safety: Generally safe with steady foot traffic; typical suburban lighting and activity along High St.
Nearby: Near shops, bars, and other restaurants on High St; accessible to residents of Preston/Thornbury.
Available: Reservations, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →