Seemor
Provincetown › Provincetown › The Mayflower
The MayflowerB+Worth Trying
Historic District, 300 Commercial St, Provincetown, MA 02657
· American restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (653 reviews)
Reservations · Takeout
Classic Provincetown seafood and Portuguese comfort fare with friendly, old-school vibes and fair prices, but consistency and occasional service missteps mean experiences can vary.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
The Mayflower delivers solid neighborhood dining with friendly, efficient service and fresh seafood when execution hits, but quality varies noticeably between visits—some diners praise perfectly cooked clams while others encounter rubbery shellfish. The Commercial Street location near the docks offers genuine Cape charm and loyal repeat customers, yet the worn decor and occasional inconsistency keep it competitive with area favorites rather than among the region's premier destinations.
Restaurant Summary
Set on bustling Commercial Street, The Mayflower channels old-school Cape charm with quick-paced, friendly service and a sprawling menu that reads like a local scrapbook. A diner-like room hums with conversation and cocktails as guests say, "the clams were sweet and perfectly cooked," while others note the space feels comfortably retro and a bit worn around the edges. The cooking leans traditional: New England seafood and Portuguese comfort favorites like kale soup, Moçambique, and broiled scrod, plus crowd-pleasing pasta and fried plates. When the kitchen is on, seafood tastes fresh and portions are hearty; on busier nights, a few diners report inconsistent execution like overcooked or gritty shellfish. Prices match the area and feel fair for the portion sizes and local seafood focus. Families do well here thanks to the kid-friendly staples on the menu: spaghetti with tomato sauce, burgers, fries, fried seafood, and garlic bread. There is no explicit kids menu, but simple options abound; picky eaters can default to pasta or chicken, while adventurous kids might enjoy chowder or lobster rolls.
At a Glance
- Classic New England seafood and Portuguese specialties with hearty portions
- Friendly, efficient service and walk-in accessibility
- Quality can vary; occasional overcooked or under-seasoned seafood
- No reservations; brief waits typical at peak times
- Good value for Cape Cod given portion sizes and freshness
What Sets It Apart
- Portuguese Cape classics
- Central Commercial Street location
- Hearty portions
What People Love
- Warm, personal staff interactions
- Fresh clams and chowder
- Portuguese kale soup comfort
- Generous lobster and seafood portions
- Nostalgic, unfussy vibe
Points of Concern
- Inconsistent execution reported: occasional rubbery or gritty shellfish and bland sauces
- Order and side mix-ups happen at busy times; follow-up can lag
- A few incidents of server rudeness or tip pressure contrasted with many positive service reports
- Pricing is Cape-typical but some items feel high to budget diners
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$42-65 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Pair Portuguese Kale Soup with Broiled Scrod for a balanced meal around $37-$39 before drinks
- For value, classic Fish and Chips ($28) plus a cup of chowder ($9) makes a satisfying light dinner
- Lobster enthusiasts: choose Hot Buttered Lobster Roll ($35) if you prefer warm, buttery richness
Perfect For
- Casual seafood night after the beach
- Mixed groups with varied tastes
- Families seeking comfort food classics
- Visitors wanting a Cape Cod staple
Location Insights
Area: Bustling seaside main street with tourist foot traffic and local charm; casual storefronts near the docks.
Safety: Generally safe, busy and well-lit with steady foot traffic during season.
Nearby: Steps from the harbor, galleries, bars, and shops along Commercial Street.
Historic DistrictThe Historic District in Provincetown is characterized by its charming, preserved architecture and a bustling, welcoming atmosphere. It features a mix of galleries, shops, and restaurants, attracting visitors looking for cultural experiences and diverse dining options, especially seafood and local specialties.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Sunday12:00–21:00
Monday11:30–21:00
Tuesday11:30–21:00
Wednesday11:30–21:00
Thursday11:30–21:00
Friday11:30–21:00
Saturday11:30–21:00
Available: Reservations, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →