Seemor

Selby'sA-Worth Trying

Name: Selby's
Address: 3001 El Camino Real, Redwood City, CA 94061, Redwood City, United States
Rating: 4.4

3001 El Camino Real, Redwood City, CA 94061 · Restaurant · 4.4/5 Google (513 reviews)

Reservations · Delivery · Takeout

Elegant, special-occasion fine dining with standout classics like Beef Wellington and Midnight Chocolate Cake, strong hospitality, premium pricing, and some inconsistency in pacing and certain dishes.

Why it gets an A- for overall quality

Selby's delivers solid A-grade performance through strong food quality anchored by signature dishes like duck and chocolate cake, paired with exceptional design and refined ambiance that creates an elegant special-occasion setting. However, inconsistent execution on certain proteins and occasional pacing delays prevent the higher distinction needed for grade A territory, while food safety concerns warrant caution on seafood selections.

Restaurant Summary

The room feels like a Peninsula time capsule in the best way—dark woods, hushed lighting, and polished hospitality that makes celebrations feel effortless. Guests mention elegant touches like handwritten cards and complimentary valet. One diner summed it up: "service made the night feel special," though a few report slow pacing and isolated curt interactions that undercut the otherwise gracious service tone. In the kitchen, the approach leans classic luxury over fireworks: Wellington, pristine tartares, truffles, and a rich chocolate cake that regulars order by name. Think elevated traditional cooking with premium sourcing rather than avant‑garde experiments; when it clicks—duck with crisp skin, dialed steak doneness, fresh tuna—it really sings. Some dishes divide opinion (lobster and the occasional Wellington miss), and supplements can quickly lift a $125 menu into splurge territory. Families should know the mood and menu skew adult. There is a burger and steak frites for simpler tastes, but the overall selection trends refined. If your crew needs kid‑friendly comfort, consider the bar for flexibility or choose elsewhere; there is no explicit kids menu and portions, pacing, and pricing are tailored to special‑occasion diners.

At a Glance

Refined, romantic ambiance with complimentary valet
Strong sommelier and server guidance for pairings
Signature Wellington and Midnight Chocolate Cake are crowd-pleasers
Pacing can be slow between courses and seating
Supplements and fees can raise bills well above prix fixe

What Sets It Apart

signature_beef_wellington
refined_old_school_ambiance
strong_sommelier_guidance

What People Love

Feeling pampered with thoughtful touches
Confident steak cookery and rich sauces
Decadent, nostalgic desserts
A bar that offers the full menu without a reservation

Points of Concern

Pacing can be slow with 30–40 minute gaps between courses on busy nights
Seafood dishes, especially lobster, receive mixed feedback and a few safety complaints
Supplements and service fees may push totals far above the base menu price
Review patterns show some polarized experiences; manage expectations on classics like Wellington

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost$125-$180 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

Steak Frites ($48) as a lower-supplement main
Selby's Burger ($27) for a simpler bar meal
Tuna Tartare ($31) plus Flan Pâtissier ($48) to share for a balanced splurge

Perfect For

Anniversary or milestone dinners
Business impress meals with classic luxury
Date nights at the bar with a la carte flexibility
Steak and classic dessert enthusiasts

Location Insights

Area: Suburban Peninsula corridor along El Camino Real; affluent residential nearby, business and shopping strip vibe.

Safety: Generally safe, well-lit arterial road; steady traffic and footfall from nearby shops.

Nearby: Near retail plazas, offices, and residential zones; convenient to Menlo Park/Woodside clientele.

Redwood ShoresRedwood Shores is a suburban neighborhood characterized by waterfront views, residential communities, and corporate campuses. The dining scene here is casual and family-friendly, with a focus on accessible, comfortable eateries catering to both local residents and nearby office workers.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday17:00–21:00 Tuesday17:00–21:00 Wednesday17:00–21:00 Thursday17:00–21:00 Friday17:00–21:00 Saturday17:00–21:00 Sunday17:00–22:00

Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout

View full analysis on Seemor →