Now primarily a corner market with liquor; the once-loved deli appears closed since 2023–2024, so come for convenience items, not made-to-order sandwiches.
Tony Baloney's Market earns a grade C+ as a neighborhood convenience stop with genuine warmth but limited food appeal in its current form. Food consistency challenges stem from the deli closure—earlier reviews celebrated made-to-order sandwiches, but recent visitors find a market layout instead, creating expectation misalignment. Friendly, welcoming owner presence and strong local loyalty provide character, but the shift from food destination to grab-and-go retail prevents a higher grade.
One caveat: Deli reportedly discontinued; several 2023–2025 reviews confirm no sandwiches