Seemor
Der Dutchman
3713 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34232
· Family restaurant, Breakfast restaurant, Restaurant
· 4.6/5 Google (11899 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Large Amish-style buffet and comfort-food menu with standout broasted chicken and pies; great for groups and families, but quality varies by timing and buffet management.
Restaurant Summary
This sprawling Sarasota staple feels warm and bustling, a place where families rotate between the buffet and the bakery case. Servers are often friendly and quick with refills, and many diners make a point to stop for pies and donuts. One guest put it simply: "Hot items were hot and the chicken hit the spot." Timing matters, though, as freshness ebbs when the room thins. The cooking leans classic Amish-style comfort over flash: broasted chicken, roast turkey, noodles, real mashed potatoes, and an abundant salad bar. Desserts are a draw, with oversized slices like banana cream and seasonal fruit pies that feel bakery-first. Expect hearty, familiar flavors more than trendiness; the menu is straightforward and satisfying when the buffet is actively refreshed. Families do well here. Kids gravitate to mac and cheese, fried chicken, mashed potatoes, soft-serve, and donuts. There is no dedicated kids menu needed because the buffet covers the bases. If you have picky eaters, come during peak periods for the best rotation and the widest selection.
At a Glance
- Big, well-run buffet during peak times with beloved broasted chicken and pies
- Excellent for families and large groups with generous portions
- Quality varies off-peak; some cold or dry buffet items reported
- Beverages not included with buffet; desserts can add up
- Isolated reports of flies at dessert cases and one illness claim
What Sets It Apart
- large_amish_style_buffet
- on_site_bakery_with_iconic_pies
- massive_group_capacity
What People Love
- That first plate of crispy broasted chicken
- Nostalgic roasts and real mashed potatoes
- Oversized banana cream and cherry pies
- Friendly service that keeps drinks coming
- One-stop complex with bakery and gift shop
Points of Concern
- Buffet freshness can lag during slower periods; plan peak times for best quality
- Some diners found items overly salty or bland depending on rotation
- Beverages not included with buffet may surprise first-timers
- Isolated cleanliness issues at bakery/dessert displays reported; majority still note clean facilities
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$28-$38 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Choose broasted chicken or roast beef a la carte if buffet appears slow
- Pair mains with real mashed potatoes and green beans for classic combo
- Add slice of pie to buffet for $1 off when offered
Perfect For
- Multi-generational family dinners
- Casual group brunches
- Pie and bakery runs
- Travelers seeking hearty comfort food
Location Insights
Area: Pinecraft area with strong Amish/Mennonite presence; casual, family-oriented, draws locals and visitors.
Safety: Generally safe with steady daytime foot traffic; large on-site complex appears well maintained per reviews.
Nearby: On Bahia Vista near residential streets; bakery, gift shop, and coffee shop attached; beaches and downtown a drive away.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday07:00–20:00
Tuesday07:00–20:00
Wednesday07:00–20:00
Thursday07:00–20:00
Friday07:00–20:00
Saturday07:00–20:00
Sunday
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →