Seemor
Yoder's Restaurant
3434 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34239
· Restaurant
· 4.6/5 Google (9359 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Beloved Sarasota spot for homestyle plates, standout pies, and famous fried chicken, with big portions and occasional inconsistency; go off-peak and save room for dessert.
Restaurant Summary
A Sarasota staple where lines form for fried chicken and pies, this bustling spot feels like a community hub with a market and gift shop attached. Expect friendly servers who keep things moving and portions that border on celebratory. One diner summed it up: “come hungry and plan for pie”. The cooking leans classic comfort over creativity: roast beef with gravy, meatloaf, and pressure-fried chicken, plus a parade of sides. When the kitchen is on, flavors are warm and satisfying; occasional critiques note bland seasoning or lukewarm plates during rushes or near closing. Desserts are the headliners, with seasonal fruit and cream pies drawing devoted fans. Families fit right in. Kids gravitate to grilled cheese, mac n cheese, and fries, and there are plenty of simple sides if you have cautious eaters. While salads and vegetable plates exist, true vegan mains are limited, so plant-based diners may assemble a meal from sides rather than entrees.
At a Glance
- Famous fried chicken and house pies draw loyal regulars
- Big portions and good value for homestyle American fare
- Peak-hour waits and occasional temperature/seasoning inconsistencies
- Specialty pie pricing can feel high to some
- Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food
What Sets It Apart
- house_baked_pies
- pressure_fried_chicken
- market_and_gift_shop
What People Love
- Nostalgic comfort flavors that feel homemade
- Crispy, juicy fried chicken when fresh from the fryer
- Pie slices generous enough to share
- Friendly, efficient service despite crowds
Points of Concern
- Lines can be long at peak; plan earlier or later dining
- Occasional bland or not-hot plates during rush and near closing
- Whole-pie pricing and holiday quality variability noted by some
- Review patterns show signs of potential manipulation (not detected); majority appear genuine
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$30-42 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Pair Half Chicken with mashed potatoes and green beans for balance
- Fish N Chips offers a reliable non-chicken option at $19.95
- Vegetable Plate plus a side salad builds a vegetarian meal
Perfect For
- Casual family dinners with hearty portions
- Pie runs and dessert cravings
- Group outings where comfort classics please most
- Travelers seeking a Sarasota institution
Location Insights
Area: Amish-Mennonite neighborhood with casual, family-oriented vibe; draws locals and visitors seeking comfort food and pies.
Safety: Generally safe, busy during meal times; well-trafficked with daytime footfall around shops and market.
Nearby: Adjacent to gift shop, market, and bakery; short drive from downtown Sarasota and beach-bound routes.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday07:00–20:00
Tuesday07:00–20:00
Wednesday07:00–20:00
Thursday07:00–20:00
Friday07:00–20:00
Saturday07:00–20:00
Sunday
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →