Seemor
Tomato Pie Pizza Joint (South Pasadena)
1130 Mission St, South Pasadena, CA 91030
· Pizza restaurant, Italian restaurant, Restaurant
· 4.6/5 Google (556 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Reliable NY-style slices and specialty pies with friendly counter service; some complaints about light toppings and occasional order hiccups.
Restaurant Summary
On Mission Street, the room feels warm and bustling with a relaxed slice-joint rhythm. Staff at the counter are friendly and quick, and the soundtrack leans classic rock. One guest summed it up: "That crisp fold and bright sauce sent me back to NY." The cooking is about classic NY-style technique with a few playful twists rather than flash—think foldable thin crust, square Sicilian, and the occasional Mac and Cheese pie. It suits people who value fundamentals: balance of sauce, cheese, and a crisp bottom. Most find quality worth the price, though a few wanted heavier toppings or quicker pickups at rush hour. Families do well here. Kids can share simple cheese or pepperoni, there is a Kids Pasta, and plenty of familiar sides like garlic knots. Gluten-free crust and vegetarian pies widen options, but note limited seating if you roll in with a big group.
At a Glance
- Crisp, foldable NY-style slices praised by former New Yorkers
- Friendly counter service and clean space
- Occasional light toppings or smaller-feeling slices for the price
- Peak-time waits and a few order accuracy issues
- Strong dietary options including gluten-free crust and vegan calzone
What Sets It Apart
- true_ny_slice_experience
- broad_style_range_including_sicilian_and_deep_dish
- strong_dietary_options_gluten_free_and_vegan_calzone
What People Love
- That true NY fold and crunch
- Balanced sauce-to-cheese ratios
- Friendly, helpful counter crew
- Variety of pie styles including Sicilian and deep dish
- Clean, relaxed space with classic tunes
Points of Concern
- Some guests felt toppings and cheese amounts were sparse on certain pies
- A few reports of long waits for online or peak-time pickups
- One incident of incorrect toppings that affected an allergy-sensitive diner
- Parking can be tight; small rear lot fills quickly
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$27-38 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Leverage gluten-free crust or penne if needed
- Vegetarians have multiple pies plus salads
- Kids Pasta keeps younger diners happy
Perfect For
- Quick slice before a movie or errands
- Casual family dinner with picky and adventurous eaters
- Gluten-free pizza seekers
- Low-key date night with beer and a pie
Location Insights
Area: Charming small-city main street with family-friendly vibe and independent shops; relaxed and community oriented.
Safety: Generally safe, walkable, and well-lit with steady foot traffic, especially evenings and weekends.
Nearby: Mission St corridor near boutiques and services; street parking plus a small rear lot used by multiple businesses.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday12:00–20:00
Tuesday12:00–20:00
Wednesday12:00–20:00
Thursday12:00–20:00
Friday12:00–21:00
Saturday12:00–21:00
Sunday12:00–20:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →