Seemor
Coastal Seafoods - St. PaulBWorth Trying
286 Snelling Ave S, St Paul, MN 55105
· Restaurant, Seafood market, Seafood restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (686 reviews)
Outstanding seafood market with a solid, casual cafe; best for buying pristine fish and oysters, with mixed but improving prepared-food experiences.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Coastal Seafoods delivers solid neighborhood appeal through strong seafood quality and knowledgeable staff guidance, particularly for oyster selection and market offerings. However, inconsistent execution in prepared cafe foods—ranging from standout fish tacos to soggy batter and overdressed slaw—prevents grade A-level reliability. The bright, bustling setting suits its market-first identity, making it a worthwhile destination for seafood enthusiasts who prioritize ingredient quality over culinary polish.
Restaurant Summary
Part seafood market, part casual cafe, Coastal Seafoods in St. Paul feels like a neighborhood hub where fish lovers stock up and linger for a bite. The room is bright and bustling, staff are often described as friendly and knowledgeable, and an oyster pro might even teach you how to shuck. One diner summed it up: "They picked perfect oysters and walked me through the flavors," which captures the market-first expertise vibe. In the cafe, the cooking leans classic: lobster rolls, fish tacos, and fish and chips with the occasional playful twist like a tuna smash burger or Nashville-style soft shell crab. When it hits, it really hits—several call the tacos the best they have had—though a few guests found batter too thick or slaw overdressed. It suits diners who value pristine seafood and straightforward preparations more than culinary fireworks. Families should fare fine with familiar options like fish and chips and tacos. There is no kids menu mentioned, but portions and formats are approachable. Prices skew premium for the lobster roll and market specials, so set expectations accordingly before promising a big splurge to the little ones.
At a Glance
- Market-grade seafood with standout oyster and sashimi guidance
- Casual counter-service cafe attached to the fish market
- Prepared food consistency varies (batter, slaw, fries)
- Premium pricing on marquee items like lobster roll
- Delivery and order timing can slip during peak periods
What Sets It Apart
- Market-grade seafood expertise
- Attached cafe for immediate tasting
- Oyster selection guidance
What People Love
- Feeling of trusted expertise at the counter
- Fresh, flavorful oysters and sashimi
- Standout fish tacos when on form
- Friendly staff that offers prep ideas
Points of Concern
- Prepared items show variability: some report soggy batter or overdressed slaw
- Premium prices on lobster roll and specials may surprise casual diners
- Wait times and delivery coordination can be inconsistent at rush hours
- Occasional brusque service or limited cuts offered at the counter
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$32-$48 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Based on reviews, prioritize oysters and sashimi-grade selections; choose tacos over fish and chips if you value lighter batter and brighter flavors
Perfect For
- Stocking up on pristine seafood to cook at home
- Casual lunch after shopping the market
- Oyster lovers seeking guidance and selection
- Quick solo bite on the patio
Location Insights
Area: Leafy residential district near colleges; mix of families and students with neighborhood foot traffic.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit corridors along Snelling Ave with steady pedestrian activity.
Nearby: Close to Macalester College, local boutiques, cafes; street parking common, can be tight at peak times.
Macalester-GrovelandMacalester-Groveland is a vibrant, residential neighborhood with a mix of historic homes and local businesses. The dining scene is casual and community-oriented, featuring a variety of ethnic eateries and family-friendly restaurants. The area is known for its walkability and proximity to Macalester College, attracting a diverse crowd that values local and fresh dining options.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday10:00–19:00
Tuesday10:00–19:00
Wednesday10:00–19:00
Thursday10:00–19:00
Friday10:00–19:00
Saturday10:00–19:00
Sunday10:00–18:00
View full analysis on Seemor →