Seemor

Cape Cod / Nantucket › Edgartown

Best Restaurants in Edgartown

7 restaurants analyzed · Cape Cod / Nantucket

Edgartown is the most formal of the Vineyard's main towns, with a dining scene that reflects its historic wealth. The restaurants here tend toward the higher end, with American and seafood the dominant options in a compact waterfront setting.

Grade Distribution

Restaurants

• 19 Raw Oyster Bar & Prime Steakhouse B+ · Seafood and steakhouse, Oyster bar — Destination-level oyster bar and steakhouse with creative seafood, lively vibe, and premium prices; food shines most of...
• Rockfish B+ · Restaurant & bar, Seafood — Casual, lively American seafood and pizza spot with standout lobster rolls and cocktails; service and noise can be...
• Biscuits B+ · Breakfast restaurant, Diner — Lively island breakfast spot known for biscuits, shrimp and grits, and generous plates; expect waits, strong service,...
• Square Rigger Restaurant B · Restaurant, Bar — Crowd-pleasing seafood and steaks with Brazilian touches, strong cocktails, and kid-friendly options, though service...
• Among the Flowers Cafe B · Cafe, Breakfast — Charming garden cafe with solid breakfast and lunch, counter ordering, and scenic outdoor seating; food is good, prices...
• Fat Ronnie's Burger Bar B · Burger restaurant, Fast casual — Crowded counter-service burger joint with build-your-own toppings and a hefty lobster roll; great for quick, tasty...
• Espresso Love B- · Cafe, Bakery — Sunny cafe with a lovely patio, strong specialty coffee program, and hearty bowls and sandwiches; expect crowds,...

Top Cuisines

• American — 6 restaurants
• Seafood — 1 restaurants

Find Your Next Meal in Edgartown

• Casual Meal restaurants in Edgartown — Quick, quality, no fuss
• Date Night restaurants in Edgartown — Romantic dining for two
• Fun with Friends restaurants in Edgartown — Something everyone will enjoy
• Family Outing restaurants in Edgartown — Kid-friendly, stress-free dining
• Solo Dining restaurants in Edgartown — Comfortable spots for dining alone
• Business Discussion restaurants in Edgartown — Professional setting, no distractions
• Vegetarian-Friendly restaurants in Edgartown
• Vegan-Friendly restaurants in Edgartown
• Gluten-Free Friendly restaurants in Edgartown
• Walk-ins Welcome restaurants in Edgartown
• Private Dining restaurants in Edgartown
• Local Gems restaurants in Edgartown
• Easy Parking restaurants in Edgartown
• Amazing Setting restaurants in Edgartown
• Great Value restaurants in Edgartown

Explore Edgartown on Seemor →